The History Chap Podcast
The History Chap Podcast
11: The Mother of Parliaments
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
England's road to parliamentary democracy has been a long and winding one, with plenty of rocks along the path.
And yet it is the liberties and curtailments of royal power from over 800 years ago that echo through to today and have inspired countless others - not least the founding fathers of the USA - on their own journeys to freedom.
This is the story of King John being forced to sign the Magna Carta by his barons in 1215.
It is also the story of Simon de Montfort, rebelling against King Henry III and calling the "Model Parliament" - which is seem, today, as the first proper parliament in England's history.
Monarchs, thereafter, might not have liked that block on their power but it was here to stay (and would shape England's history for hundreds of years).
Join my Supporter's Club
11: The Mother of Parliaments
One of Britain’s most iconic images is that of the Houses of Parliament.
It is like a bedrock of the nation.
Okay, forget that the building that we now know was built in the Victorian period and forget, also that most people identify the Queen Elizabeth II tower with its bell - Big Ben - as parliament.
Rather like most of Britain’s history what we see know didn’t just happen overnight.
The road to parliamentary democracy has been a long and winding one, with plenty of rocks along the path.
And yet it is the liberties and curtailments of royal power from over 800 years ago that echo through to today and have inspired countless others - not least the founding fathers of the USA - on their own journeys to freedom.
The British Houses of Parliament, rightly, calls itself the Mother of Parliaments.
But where did this journey begin?
Because back in the Norman & early Plantagenet period England was ruled, arbitrarily by kings - William The Conqueror, Henry I, Henry II, Richard the Lionheart.
Yet that was about to change.
When Richard I (the Lionheart) died in 1199 after a 120 year reign (most of it spent outside of England fighting various wars) the crown passed to his younger brother - John.
King John inherited a country short of cash - mainly because Richard had emptied the coffers fighting his wars and then getting captured and held to ransom.
Within a year of his ascension John decided that he too would go to war with France.
Now, fighting the French has become a bit of an English past time.
But there is a catch.
If you wrack your brain thinking of ALL the wars and battles between England (later Great Britain) and France certain names comes to mind: Edward III, Henry V, the Duke of Marlborough at Blenheim, Wellington at Waterloo, Nelson at Trafalgar.
They all have something in common.
They were victorious.
The English don’t mind fighting France, or paying to fight France, as long as you are a winner.
Losing is not an option.
Name a British or English leader who lost….you’ll be hard pressed.
…enter King John.
John’s war lasted almost all of his 16 year reign and the outcome was a disaster. All of the lands owned by his father and brother in northern France were lost, including Normandy itself.
All that remained of that mighty Angevin empire created by his father, Henry II, was Gascony in the south west of France. (Bordeaux down to the Pyrenees) remained under his control.
No one likes a loser….
At the end of the day people are willing to be taxed to fund a winning war.
But even a losing war had to be paid for.
And thanks to Richard’s escapades there was no pot of money sitting in the royal coffers.
John had to raise cash.
So he came up with a great money earning wheeze. For a town to have a market it needed a royal charter so John offered them for sale. Pay John money to make money…as win-win solution.
One of these new boroughs was established on the banks of the River Mersey in the north west of England. It drew its name from two old English words describing the place, - dark or muddy water (Lifer) and creek or pool (Pol).
And there we have the origins of Liverpool.
But there was only a certain amount of new charters he could sell and John was way off his financial goal.
So he resorted to a tax called - Scutage.
Traditional feudal system, from William The Conqueror down, had vested all land in the King.
He bestowed land to the nobility who in return provided troops for war.
Well, Scutage, did away with that requirement and in return the nobility had to pay a tax instead.
The tax was fixed at 3 marks per knight.
That equated to something like a third of a sailors annual pay - so multiply that by however many knights you had to supply the king and it became a costly affair for the nobility.
In fact, King Join was so keen on this Scutage tax that he imposed it 11 times during his 17 year reign. To put that into context he imposed it as many times as Kings Stephen, Henry II and Richard The Lionheart had imposed it in the previous 64 years!
The nobility chaffed at these impositions on their wealth and opposition galvanised around a group of northern nobles, led by William de Mowbray.
Whilst John was attempting rule arbitrarily like his predecessors the nobles argued that a king should rule in accordance to customs and law and, more importantly, take advice from the leading men in the realm (like them!)
De Mowbray gathered an army at Northampton and this so-called “Army of God” rapidly took control of Lincoln, Exeter and the capital, London.
This was the biggest challenge to roll authority since the Norman Conquest.
Having lost most of the Angevin Empire was John about to lose the throne of England too?
The Archbishop of Canterbury mediated between the two sides and a month after the barons had taken London King John was forced to agree to their demands.
On the 15th June 1215, at Runnymede on the Thames (not far from Windsor Castle) he signed a Grand Charter (or Magna Carta) consisting of 63 clauses.
The Carta (charter) only became the Great Charter (Magna Carta) two years later to differentiate from the Charter of the Forest of 1217.
The Magna Carta is often seen as the foundation stone of England’s freedoms which ultimately led to democracy (and was cited by parliamentarians in the Civil War as well as the founding fathers of the United States) but its purpose back in 1215 was to confirm the Barons feudal rights rather than to usher in parliamentary democracy.
Yes the kings powers were reigned in so but only so that the barons could exercise more of theirs, particularly around inheritance and restricting the Crown’s ability to tax their wealth.
Nevertheless the rights of serfs were mentioned in 3 clauses and more generally the Magna Carta protected all freemen from illegal imprisonment and gave them access to swift justice.
A council of 25 barons was established to oversee that the Carta’s provisions were adhered to.
The rebels ensured that the council was packed with hardliners including Robert de Vere, Earl of Oxford and de Mowbray.
Interestingly, it was one of Mowbray’s descendants - his great-great-great-great grandson whose arrival turned the tide in favour of the Yorkists' at the Battle of Towton during the Wars of the Roses.
Neither side was really committed to keeping their side of the bargain.
By September of that year, King John had obtained a Papal Bull (basically a command or “get out of jail free” card from the Pope) absolving him of his responsibilities under the Grand Charter.
The Barons had enough and renounced their loyalty to John.
In what is called the First Barons War, John initially swept across the country defeating the rebels at every turn.
Only London held out.
From there the rebels invited Louis, the son of the King of France, to lead them and take the crown.
Louis landed in Kent in 1216.
John now had a serious rebellion on his hands.
Worse was to come as he took a short-cut ac ross the tidal marshes of The Wash in East Anglia.
A baggage train containing the crown Jewells of England became stranded in the mud and as the tide rose, the crown Jewells disappeared beneath the waters, never to be seen again.
It was almost a metaphor for his grip on the kingdom.
And then to cap it all, John caught dysentry and died. He was two months short of his 50th birthday.
There has only ever been one King John of England and with his track record you can see why future royals have tried to avoid the name.
John was succeeded by his 9-year old son, Henry.
As London was in rebel hands, Henry was crowned King Henry III at Gloucester Cathedral.
His is the only coronation since 1066 not to have taken place in Westminster Abbey.
William Marshall, Earl of Pembroke, acting as regent for the young king conducted a highly successful military campaign against the rebels, defeating them at Lincoln in may 1217 and then winning a naval battle off Sandwich in Kent, when a fleet bringing reinforcements to Louis from France was scattered.
In a clever move, the young King with Marshall’s support reaffirmed the Magna Carta.
Starring military defeat in the face and now presented with a young English king whom they didn’t actually have a dispute with any more nobles drifted away from the rebel cause.
By the end of the year, Louis had signed a peace treaty and left England.
The future looked bright.
But it wasn’t to last.
Just two years later, Marshall, the loyal servant to Henry II, his two sons, and now his grandson died.
When Henry came of age the barons started to lose their influence as the king ruled in his own right.
Furthermore, Henry began to rely on French advisors rather than his nobles to steer his realm.
I said earlier that a constant in English history was fighting France.
Another constant, for much of England’s history has been the nobilities desire to be close to the power of the crown.
Going back to Anglo Saxon Witangemot (or Witan) Kings of England had traditionally taken counsel from their senior nobles, advisors and churchmen.
These gatherings persisted after the Norman Conquest.
By the 1230’s they were no longer Witans.
Instead they took the name from the French meaning “an occasion for speaking” - Parliament.
Yet, as the name implied these gatherings were “an occasion for speaking”.
The leading men of the land offered advice to the King.
The King was not accountable to them, they did not have to listen to them.
And now that Henry was an adult and relying on his French advisors, this King was certainly not listening to them.
And as the 13th century rolled along, the nobles were starting to feel excluded from the process.
Not good news for Henry III.
Oh and another thing the nobles liked, was hanging on to their wealth.
And here was another problem.
Henry wanted their cash to fund another fruitless war in France and also to buy the kingdom of SicilySicilySicilySicily from the Pope for his younger son, Edmund.
To find the cash for these endeavours, he forced his county sheriffs (such as the Sheriff of Nottingham) to squeeze their local populations for the extra funds.
As a side note, the stories of Robin Hood started to circulate during the reign of Henry III.
By April 1258 the resentment at the swinging attacks on their wealth and their exclusion from power led to 7 powerful nobles agreeing to make a stand against what they saw as royal oppression.
Their leader was the Earl of Leicester, a French-born nobleman, Simon de Montfort.
Interestingly, de Montfort was marred to Eleanor Plantagenet, daughter of King John.
So he was King Henry’s brother-in-law.
In response to this growing pressure from his nobles (and mindful of what had happened to his father,) the King issued the Provisions of Oxford in which he agreed to govern through a council of 15 barons (elected by the barons) and also to call three parliaments a year.
For the first time in English history a king (best under duress) had agreed that he could not govern without the consent of his subjects.
And then the King headed off to France to further his claims to the lands of his ancestors.
Which was a nifty move because, Parliament couldn’t open without the king….and the king wasn’t in England!
And then he took a leaf out of his father’s book - he persuaded the Pope to issue another Papal Bull absolving him from his agreement.
The nobles were furious by this about-turn.
In 1263 de Montford convened a council of the barons in Oxford and they marched on London.
London rose in revolt against the king during which 500 Jews were massacred.
In fact, de Montfort was an anti-semite who endorsed pogroms by his supporters against Jews throughout England. It is a stain on his reputation as the architect of parliamentary democracy.
With a rebellion back in England, Henry appealed to the King of France to arbitrate which he duly did and strangely enough found in favour of his fellow king.
In April 1264 civil war broke out between the supporters of de Montfort and those of the king.
Henry arrived back in England with an army but in May of that year, outside Lewes, in Sussex, the king’s numerically superior army met a shock defeat at the hands of the rebels.
The King and his son, Prince Edward were captured.
Henry became a puppet king as de Montfort seized the reigns of power.
De Montfort proceeded to call a parliament on behalf of the king which met in January 1265.
Not only were nobles called to attend but de Montfort also summoned 4 knights from each shire and burgesses from each major town.
For the first time non-nobles attended a parliament.
But the rebel baron overplayed his hand.
Growing mistrust over his true ambitions alienated a growing number of nobles.
Prince Edward managed to escape and gathered a fresh army to challenge de Montfort.
On the morning of the 4th August 1265 it all came to a head at Evesham in Worcestershire.
The Prince positioned his massive army (perhaps 18,000 strong) on a hill to the north of the town.
This picture, taken when I visited the battlefield is roughly from Edward’s position looking down on the town.
With black thunder clouds forming in the sky above, de Montfort led his 6,000 rebels out of the town.
The result was never really in question - the rebels were massacred. Something like 4,000 of them were killed in the fields outside the town.
Before the battle Edward had personally selected 12 of his best knights to act as a stalking party to spy out and kill de Montfort.
They carried out their task.
Simon de Montfort was dead, but the precedent that he had established - both of a king governing through his subjects and a parliament of not just nobles but also of commoners had been established.
Henry, freed and restored to the throne, was to call the commons to parliament three more times during the remaining 7 years of his reign.
Henry III reigned for 56 years. Only George III, Queen Victoria and Queen Elizabeth II have sat on the English throne for longer.
4 copies of the Magna Carta survive - one is at Lincoln Cathedral, one at Salisbury Cathedral and the remaining 2 are at the British Library.
Slowly its clauses were repealed as they were superseded by new laws or became obsolete such as clause 33 which sought the removal of fishing weirs on the River Thames.
However, 3 clauses remain:
One that the rights of freeman outlined in the charter should be protected;
Another that protects the rights and liberties of the City of London.
And the most powerful, most impactful one - Clause 29: “No free man shall be taken or imprisoned…except by…lawful judgement of his peers’ and “We will not deny or defer to any man either justice or right.”
The parliament of 1265 represented the future house of commons.
30 years later, In 1295 Edward I summoned what became known as The Model Parliament.
It was based upon the presentation that de Montfort had introduced - nobles, clergy, knights of the shires and representatives of the towns.
It became the model of future parliaments.
Initially the 49 Lords and 292 representatives of the Commons sat together.
By 1341 the two groups were sitting separately - the Lords and The Commons.
By the Tudors, 300 years after de Montfort's radical parliament, the two chambers had been given the names that exist to this day - The House of Lords & the House of Commons.
Together they are The Houses of Parliament.
The road to the parliamentary democracy that we now have with a constitutional monarch had a long way to go, but in 1265 the seeds for the Model Parliament had been sown - a parliament not just for the nobles but for the commoners too.
Henceforth, the precedent had also been set that parliament was not there to merely parley or talk, not to simply advise but the monarch would in future need their support to govern and in particular to raise taxes.
British democracy has been over 800 years in the making.
So next time you are in London looking the 19th century Houses of Parliament or when you pour HP sauce onto your bacon butty or full English breakfast…remember that you are looking at an 800 year old story of the “Mother of Parliaments.”