The History Chap Podcast
The History Chap Podcast
10: Anarchy & Lionheart
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Less than 60 years after the Norman Conquest, William's son, King Henry I was facing a succession crisis.
It was a crisis that would, ultimately, lead to a civil war and the first time in England's history that a woman would be proclaimed Queen of England.
This crisis ushered in a new royal dynasty...one that was to rule England for over 300 years...the Plantagenets.
Join my Supporter's Club
Ultimately, the Plantagenets would tear themselves apart in the Wars of the Roses but this is the story of their founder and his wayward sons.
Henry II, who ruled from the Scottish border to the Pyrenees.
This fiery king was responsible for the murder of his own Archbishop of Canterbury and then a series of wars with his sons.
One of those sons, was to become one of England's most famous warrior kings, Richard I (the Lionheart).
10: Anarchy & Lionheart
As the boat left port that night, the young party goers could not have realised the danger they were in.
As the oarsmen pulled clear of the harbour they picked up speed.
No one saw the submerged rock on that dark night.
The ship hit it at full power.
In the ensuing disaster only one person survived.
Into that silent, watery grave had slipped 300 people.
Including the heir to the English throne.
The sinking of the White Ship in 1120 was a disaster.
The heir to the throne of England, William Adelin, was son of King Henry I, and grandson of William The Conqueror - who had defeated Harold at the Battle of Hastings just 54 years previously.
King Henry’s only surviving legitimate heir is Matilda who was married to the Holy Roman Emperor.
Widowed in 1125, Empress Matilda married Geoffrey Plantagenet, Count of Anjou three years later.
When Henry I died in 1135 the nobles were in turmoil.
The old king had nominated Matilda as his successor but…she was a woman!
The nobles opted for a man - her cousin, Stephen of Blois.
Matilda was not best pleased.
She thought that hers was the legitimate claim to the crown of England…and she was not alone.
Her half-brother, Robert of Gloucester (an illegitimate son of Henry I) gathered an army to press home her claim.
Meanwhile, her uncle, King David I of Scotland invaded the north of England on her behalf….as well as helping himself to Cumbria and most of Northumbria in the process.
By 1139, the King of Scotland occupied all of England north of the River Tees.
No Scottish king would ever control this much of England again until King James VI became King James I of England over 400 years later.
Meanwhile in that same year (1139), Matilda finally landed in England but she was quickly besieged ivy Stephen n Arundel Castle.
However, in a case of misjudged leniency, Stephen accepted that Matilda herself had not rebelled against him, just her half-brother.
So he allowed her to leave the castle. Upon which, Matilda raced straight to half-brother Robert’s army in Bristol.
By now with the Scots occupying the north, the rebels controlling the west Stephen had, not surprisingly taken his eye off the ball in what remained of his kingdom.
Nobles seized the opportunity to construct unlicensed castles, whilst the church demanded more freedoms in exchange for their support of Stephen’s precarious position.
Not surprisingly, this period of civil war became known as “The Anarchy”.
And then it got worse…at least for Stephen.
In 1141 whilst besieging Lincoln Castle he was captured by forces loyal to Matilda and taken in chains to Bristol.
This was a decisive moment for Matilda….and she managed to blow it.
First off, by shackling the anointed king, she suddenly created sympathy for Stephen.
But she managed to crank it up for faulty PR campaign to the next level.
Residing at the royal palace at Westminster, Matilda prepared for her coronation.
A tradition had grown up that before a coronation a king (or queen in this new case) would receive the merchants of London and hear their petitions for various tax concessions.
In return they would pledge their support for the king.
Matilda wasn’t having any of that!
She sent them packing.
And the citizens of London raised their militia and prepared to march down the road to Westminster.
Now it was Matilda’s turn to be sent packing and she fled to Oxford.
Could it get any worse?
Well, yes it could.
Because half-brother Robert, was now captured by troops loyal to the king.
Without her most capable military commander Matilda’s camping was now riderless and she agreed to a prisoner swap - Robert for King Stephen.
And the now free (and slightly ticked off ) Stephen immediately attacked Matilda at Oxford.
Once more the rebel Empress was forced to go on the run, ending up at Wallingford Castle.
The last time Wallingford appeared in our story of England was when her grandfather, William the Conqueror, had crossed the River Thames here and marched on London after his victory at the Battle of Hastings.
The ensuing 6 years were effectively a stalemate.
Finally in 1147, Robert died of natural causes at Bristol Castle (he was 57) and the civil war petered out.
But not for long….
6 years later (1153), Empress Matilda’s son from her marriage to Geoffrey of Anjou - Henry Plantagenet arrived in England to press his mother’s cause and, more importantly his own claim to the throne.
The crucial moment came when Henry and Stephen’s armies met at Wallingford.
Camped on opposite sides of the River Thames, the two sides refused to engage and a truce was declared.
Stephen & Henry signed a treaty at Winchester recognising that Henry would succeed the king upon his death. Matilda, who was still alive, stood aside for her son.
And just over a year later, Stephen died and the 21 year-old Henry duly became king - Henry II, the first of the royal house of Plantagenet.
Henry inherited an England that was approaching some sort of “failed state.”
Nobles had erected illegal castles - strongholds to both enhance their local power and to potentially defy the king.
The Church had extended their power.
Scotland ruled the north of England.
Henry had his work cut out.
First off, Henry decided to kick the Scots out of England.
Back in 1147 he had promised the north to King David (his great-uncle) in return for his support against Stephen.
But William had died the previous year leaving his 11-year old grandson (Malcolm IV) on the throne of Scotland.
And anyway, Henry seemed to regard that promise to William rather like a modern politician views promises during an election campaign…
He now demanded and received the lands back from young King Malcolm in return for Malcolm reviving feudal lands in England.
Job 1 completed.
It didn’t take too much more an energetic, warlike king, with no rivals to his crown to bring the nobles to heel.
Job 2 completed.
That just left the church to sort out.
Henry II’s reign will be remembered for three key challenges:
Turbulent Priests
Turbulent family
Turbulent Ireland….the last might have not been turbulent if he had left it alone but hey ho…
As I said earlier, the period known as “The Anarchy” had enabled the church to extend both its influence and, more importantly, its independence from the crown.
In particular, the church had through its own courts complete independence from the crown.
Priests, no matter what crime they committed, were tried by their peers rather than having to face the king’s justice like the rest of his subjects.
Unsurprisingly, these church courts were rather lenient when it came to punishing one of their own.
Not least when blood had been spilled.
A priest who committed murder (and yes they did) would be defrocked. Meanwhile in the king’s courts any other subject would face death or mutilation.
In the Constitution of Clarendon (1164) King Henry sought to curtail this independence.
The church leaders were horrified.
In particular, they were horrified with Henry’s decree that any priest who was defrocked was no longer and the protection of the church and would face the king’s justice.
This put Henry at loggerheads with the church…and in particular with the Archbishop of Canterbury; Thomas Becket.
Becket, who was not a priest by training and had previously been Henry’s Lord Chancellor, was a political appointee who had gone “native”.
The church could not have found a stronger defender and Henry could not have found a more challenging opponent.
The impasse became so bitter that Becket was forced to flee into exile shortly after opposing the Constitution of Clarendon and was only allowed back into England after 6 years in 1170.
If Henry thought that his Archbishop would have used his exile to turn over a new leaf he was sadly mistaken.
The returning prodigal son excommunicated three of the most senior bishops in England - York, London & Salisbury - for anointing Henry’s eldest son as future king without Becket’s presence or approval.
Henry was livid and in response to his rage, 4 knights rode to Canterbury and there on the 29th December 1170, they famously assassinated the Archbishop in his own cathedral.
The murder shocked Europe and within 3 years, Becket had been canonised as St. Thomas Becket and his shrine at Canterbury cathedral became a major centre of Christian pilgrimage - famously captured in Geoffrey Chaucer’s “Canterbury Tales.”
If Thomas Becket was a holy opponent, Henry met more unholy alliances amongst his own family.
In the same year that Becket was canonised, three of his 5 sons rebelled against him.
They were joined by Scotland, France, Brittany & Flanders.
Just to cap it all, their mother (& Henry’s wife), Eleanor of Aquitaine also joined this so-called “Great Revolt”.
Henry was forced to conduct a major military campaign against his own family and only by securing a victory over the English rebels at Fornham All Saints (outside Bury St. Edmunds in Suffolk) and capturing the Scottish King at the battle of Alnwick, was he able to secure his position.
His sons were to rebel on two more occasions during his reign.
The third of Henry’s turbulences lay to the west.
But by and large, Ireland had been left to its own devices by the Romans, the Britons, and the Anglo Saxons.
But in 1167 that all changed.
It was in that year that the King of Leicester was deposed by the High King of Ireland.
Arriving in England, he appealed to King Henry for support to regain his throne.
Henry decided to not personally intervene but gave him permission to recruit mercenaries instead.
And so he enlisted the support of Richard de Clare, Earl of Pembroke - known to history as “Strongbow” - to help him regain his thrown.
If there is one thing Normans liked it was fighting and land. And de Clare saw an opportunity for both.
So reauitiung an army he landed in Ireland, defeated the local force es and re-instated the King of Leicester.
So far so good.
Have you ever done a job for someone else and wondered exactly why they were getting all the glory or rewards for all your hard efforts?
Well, that thought crossed de Clare’s mind back in 1167.
So get got rid of the King of Leinster.
And now Henry suddenly became interested in Ireland.
Maybe he saw rich pickings.
He certainly saw an opportunity to give lands to his youngest son (and the only one who didn’t rebel against him) Prince John.
Most probably, he didn’t want one of his nobles carving out lands outside of his jurisdiction.
Whichever reason it was, in 1171 Henry crossed to Ireland and established his own authority in the area that de Clare had conquered.
And so began the long and tortured history of the English (and then. British) in Ireland.
By 1189, Henry II had been on the throne for 35 years.
In what is sometimes referred to as the Angevin Empire his realm stretched from the Scottish border in the north to Ireland in the west and then down through France all the way to the Pyrenees.
But once more the 56 year old king was faced by a rebellion from one of his sons. This time it was from his oldest surviving son and heir, Richard.
The rebellion was conducted in Henry’s French possessions rather than in England and so over to France went Henry.
Henry, however, met his match in Richard who (as we will see) was pretty good as this fighting lark.
Facing defeat and suffering from a stomach ulcer he retreated to Chinon Castle in his native Anjou and there on the 6th July he died.
Richard the rebel was now Richard the King.
He was crowned at Westminster Abbey in September 1189.
During his coronation Jewish merchants made the short journey from London to Westminster to present the new king with presents.
The Jews had originally arrived in England at the request of William the Conqueror and they performed a key economic function.
The medieval catholic church forbade usury (the charging of interest on loans).
So why would you lend someone money if all you were going to get back was the same amount. You might as well keep it yourself.
The Jews - as non Christians - were except from this rule. They could charge interest.
And so the wheels of the economy were oiled.
If a merchant, or a noble, or a king needed to borrow money, the Jewish community were happy to oblige…at a price.
Not surprisingly some Jews had done very well from money lending.
And also not surprisingly many people envied and resented them.
Add to that a bigoted form of Christianity that blamed the Jews for the death of Jesus (as well as more lurid rumours that they sacrificed christian children) then you had volatile situation for England’s Jewish population.
Under those circumstances, having the king’s favour and protection was very important.
Hence their appearance at the coronation.
Historically, Jews had been forbidden from attending coronations and when they arrived, nobles took it upon themselves to strip and flog the new king’s Jewish subjects. What happened to their gifts is debatable but they certainly didn’t leave with them!
Upon hearing of this attacks, Londoners now attacked the city’s Jewish population - looting, arson and murder were visited on the minority.
Richard attempted to restore order by ordering the execution of certain ring-leaders but the new king was faced by a formidable opposition of nobles and churchmen, who for a variety of bigoted and also commercial reasons had supported the riot (especially if they owed money to a Jew).
The new king then issued an edict protecting the Jews but this was only loosely enforced by those same nobles whom I have just mentioned.
Anyway. Richard had more important things to do with his time than protecting England’s Jews.
For, he had vowed to go on Crusade and re-capture the holy city of Jerusalem, which had fallen to the muslim forces of Saladin just two years before.
A new tax - the Saladin tithe - was raised to pay for the military expedition.
The Saladin tithe took a 10% of every man’s wealth. - a huge amount of cash.
In the summer of 1190, less than a year after his coronation he left the shores of England heading east.
Within weeks of his departure, the mob (added by the nobility and the clergy) once more turned on the Jewish population. Riots and massacres took place in Norwich, Lincoln, Stamford, Bury St. Edmunds and Lynn. In the worst excess, 150 Jews (almost the entire Jewish population) died in York.
Meanwhile Richard fought his way through Sicily and Cyprus (against fellow Christians) before arriving in the Holy Land in 1191.
There he captured the ports of Acre and Jaffa (murdering several thousand muslim prisoners in the process) before inflicting a famous victory over Saladin at the battle of Arsuf.
Richard led the Crusading army to within sight of Jerusalem itself but didn’t have the manpower to launch an assault.
By the end of 1192, he had signed a peace treaty with Saladin and headed home.
However, he ended up shipwrecked and captured, first by Leopold of Austria, and then by the Holy Roman Emperor. In both cases these men had scores to settle with Richard from previous slights during his crusade.
The Emperor demanded a ransom of 150,000 Marks - a figure similar to the entire amount raised by the Saladin Tithe - to release Richard.
A huge tax raising initiative back in England was headed up by the King’s brother - Prince John and his mother Eleanor of Aquitaine.
Finally after two years in prison Richard was released.
After a quick return to England, he was off again, this time fighting various rebels in his French domains who were being supported by the King of France.
It was whilst besieging a minor castle in France that Richard was hit by a crossbow bolt in the shoulder. His wound became infected and in April 1199 he died.
Richard spent less than two years in total of his 10 year reign in England.
His crusade and then ransom bled the country dry.
England’s Jews had been robbed and massacred with impunity.
And yet he remains one of England’s most famous and revered kings.
Maybe it was his very obvious talents as a warrior - Without a doubt once of the greatest Christian crusader commanders and his victory at Arsuf inflicted one of the very few defeats that Saladin ever suffered.
And let’s face it, we all like a winner!
Maybe it was the very fact that he went on a holy war that captured the imagination.
Legend attributes Richard for introducing St. George as England’s patron saint.
He certainly visited St. George’s tomb and sought his divine protection.
It also seems that he used the flag of St. George that was flown by merchant ships from Genoa in Italy.
St. George, however did not become England’s patron saint for another 150 years.
So apart from being a winning warrior king what else did he leave England?
In 1198, a year before his death, Richard ordered a new Great Seal to mark his orders and laws.
For the first time ever, the Great Seal of England consisted of three lions.
It remains one of the iconic symbols of England to this day.
It has been just 133 years since the Norman invasion.
Since then Williams grandchildren - Matilda and Stephen - had fought a civil war - which had led to a new royal family - the Plantagenets.
The English have arrived in Ireland - a relationship that still impacts today.
An Archbishop was martyred, whose is still remembered in church and school names to this day - St. Thomas Becket
And an English king has been on crusade. A warrior king who appears in the tales of Robin Hood (remember Sean Connery’s appearance in “Robin Hood Prince of Thieves”?
And England has a new emblem - Three Lions.
The golden thread of history continues to weave its story and connects us to our past.