The History Chap Podcast
The History Chap Podcast
The Wars of the Roses (Part 6 of 6) - Dawn of the Tudors
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
We left off last time with Henry victorious on the battlefield at Bosworth and famously having Richard III’s gold cornet placed on his head by Lord Stanley.
Richard’s body, striped naked was slung over the back of a horse and taken to Leicester for public display before being buried in Greyfrairs church.
The Plantagenet dynasty was at an end.
Henry was not a Plantagenet. His mother, Margaret Beaufort was, but his father’s side were from an ancient Welsh noble line.
His new dynasty bore their name: the House of Tudor.
Victorious on the battlefield Henry may have been but secure he was not.
For a start, how legitimate was his claim?
Henry’s claim was not through his grandfather, Owain Tudor marrying the dowager Queen of England, it was through his mother Margaret Beaufort.
She was related to her great-great grandfather (Edward III) through John of Gaunts affair with Katherine Swynford. Whilst the illegitimate Beauforts had been legitimised did they have a claim to the throne?
If you remember, Henry IV had declared that his, now legitimate, half brothers & sisters together with their offspring were not in the line of succession.
However, this was never made official through an Act of Parliament.
So what we had was a dead king’s wish.
I want you to go back & recall our first talk - a lot of water has flowed under the bridge sInce then!Do you remember that we went back up stream and briefly put Edward III (& Henry IV) into context by teaching the kings since 1066?
Do you remember Matilda?
Her father, Henry I’s dying wish was for Matilda to inherit his crown.
But the nobles decided to ignore his wish and gave the crown to her cousin, Stephen.
We ended up with a civil war between Stephen & Matilda which resulted in a treaty by which Matilda’s son inherited the throne upon Stephen’s death.
And so he did - Henry II, the first of the Royal House of Plantagenet, the same house that had now been pushed aside by Henry Tudor.
Anyway, the point is that the nobles ignored the dead king’s wishes.
That set a precedent.
So, the Beauforts (well certainly Margaret & her son Henry Tudor) together with supporters of the House of Lancaster could ignore the wishes, because that’s all they were, of Henry IV.
Without a specific Act of Parliament barring them, the Beauforts could argue the toss that they were in the line of succession.
And they did but it was certainly not cast iron.
The practical reality is that Henry’s claim to the throne had a lot more to do with killing Richard III at Bosworth than having a river of blue blood flowing through his veins.
Compare that to the House of York.
Richard of York had a straight (legitimate) line back to Edward III through both his mother and his father. Thus, so too did his children - Edward IV, Richard III, George Duke of Clarence, Margaret Duchess of Burgundy and Elizabeth de La Pole. And thus their children.
Putting it very frankly, Henry Tudor’s claim to the throne was weak.
If there hadn’t been a Lancaster / Yorkist rivalry he would probably have ended up as an obscure Welsh nobleman.
But that wasn’t the case.
And now, with his claim to the throne via his mother and by God’s divine intervention at Bosworth (The “God Card” was always a useful card to play in medieval England) he was crowned king Henry VII at Westminster Abbey on the 30th October.
To re-enforce the royal lineage of his dynasty, Henry married Elizabeth of York, the daughter of Edward IV and Elizabeth Woodville, sister of the Princes in the Tower.
Their children would have the blood of both the House of Lancaster and the House of York in their veins.
Bosworth had not been a major battle.
Total losses of 1200 compared to the bloodbath at Towton.
Almost no major nobles (apart from the Duke of Norfolk) had been killed. Maybe because there were no Dukes of Somerset available to be killed or executed!
Its significance was that King Richard III, the head of the House of York, had been killed.
But, just because the head of the house has been killed didn’t mean that Henry Tudor (now Henry VII) was safe.
The death of Richard of York at the battle of Wakefield had not destroyed the Yorkist cause (far from it).
The defeat at Tewksbury and the murder of Henry VI had not destroyed the Lancastrian cause.
All the Yorkists needed was another leader to rally around.
But who?
10 years ago, there were 9 male descendants of Richard of York alive.
Now there were just 3.
There was the son of George Duke of Clarence - Edward Earl of Warwick.
He was just 10.
His father had died a traitor and therefore he was ruled out.
Nevertheless, he was the grandson of Richard of York (and also of Warwick the Kingmaker) as well as nephew of Edward IV and Richard III.
Arguably as strong a claim as Henry - although there was the dad dying a traitor problem.
The only other man left standing was John de la Pole, Earl of Lincoln and his younger brother, Edmund.
Do you remember his name.
I mentioned him briefly in the last talk.
When Richard III’s son had died, Richard had made John heir presumptive.
But it had never been confirmed, least of all by Richard, who wanted to produce his own heir. Remember, when Ann Neville died he was on the look out for a new wife. Rumours were rife that he wanted to enter into a creepy marriage to his own niece.
More solid evidence, is that he was interested in marrying the sister of the King of Portugal.
So why confirm John when there were other potential options for Richard to pursue and create an heir apparent.
And remember that Richard was only 33 when he was killed.
Nevertheless, John de la Pole was a potential leader.
As he was 25, he could rule in his own right, unlike his 10 year old cousin, Edward of Warwick.
His mother was Edward IV’s sister. And if Margaret Beaufort could give Henry a legitimate line to Edward III so could his mother.
That was it… or was it?
What if Edward V or his brother had not been murdered?
What if they were still alive, waiting to return?
Enter Lambert Simnel.
In May 1487, 18 months after Henry’s coronation a rival was proclaimed king.
Lambert Simnel was born of humble origins but priest , Richard Simon had tutored him with enough reading, learning and etiquette to pass him off as a noble.
After initially claiming that he was Richard of York (the younger prince in the tower), Simon changed his story and claimed that Lambert Simnel was in fact Edward Earl of Warwick, who had escaped from the Tower.
Simon took Lambert to Ireland where there was still strong Yorkist support and there on the 24th May 1487, in Christchurch cathedral in Dublin, Lambert was crowned King Edward VI.
And then he was joined by none other than John de la Pole, Earl of Lincoln, supported by 2,000 Swiss mercenaries supplied by Richard & Edwards other sister - Margaret Duchess of Burgundy.
Did the earl of Lincoln really believe that this was his cousin, Warwick, or did he see him as a useful pawn in his own ambitions for the throne?
Similarly, did the Duchess of Burgundy see Simnel as her nephew (she publicly claimed he was) or was she just looking for any reason to level the score with Henry Tudor?
We don’t know.
What we do know is that on the 4th June, Simnel, the Earl of Lincoln, their Swiss mercenaries and a force of Irish landed in Lancashire.
Covering an impressive 200 miles in 5 days, they crossed the Pennines and moved south pushing the Royalist army under Edward Woodville, Lord Scales, back through Sherwood Forest to Nottingham.
On the 14th June Woodville (Lord Scales) was joined by troops led by two survivors of the battle of Bosworth: Lord Strange (remember him - Lord Stanley’s hostage son, who was supposed to be beheaded) and Rhys Ap Thomas (the man purported to have killed Richard III).
Behind them came the main royalist army led Henry himself together with the ever faithful Jasper Tudor and John de la Vere (13th Earl of Oxford).
On the 15th June, Henry moved his army eastwards along the old Fosse Road from Nottingham towards Newark, following the south bank of the River Trent.
And just outside the village of East Stoke they found the rebel army, which had crossed the Trent, formed up ready for them.
The Royalist army of 12,000 outnumbered Simbert & Lincoln’s rebel, who stood at 8,000.
Just as at Bosworth, Henry let the Earl of Oxford take tactical command.
As Royalist arrows rained down the rebels charged off the high ground.
A wild charge of Irish fury and disciplined, battle-hardened Swiss mercenaries.
The Royalist line buckled but Oxford held his men and his archers started to slaughter the lightly armoured Irish. The Swiss mercenaries were armed with hand guns but could not match the archers rate of fire.
And then Oxford ordered his own charge.
The rebels were trapped between the advancing Royal army and the River Trent.
It was a bloodbath.
Over 4,000 rebels died and anything between 500-3,000 Royalists. John de la Pole, Earl of Lincoln was killed in the fighting.
Lambert Simnel was captured.
Whilst some say that Bosworth was the end of the Wars of The Roses it is fair to say that the Battle of Stoke Fields was. There was never another battle of this size in England until the English Civil War, 160 years later.
Henry had survived.
He realised that Simnel was just a puppet and put him to work in the royal kitchens.
But it was not over yet.
Then in 1490 another pretender to the throne appeared - Perkin Warbeck.
Once again, backed by Margaret of Burgundy (what is it with these Margarets in the Wars of the Roses?) he claimed to be Richard, the younger of the two Princes in the Tower.
He attempted a landing at Deal in Kent but his force was defeated before he could even land.
Further attempts to raise a rebellion in the north and in Ireland failed completely.
In September 1497, he landed in Cornwall with just 120 men and gathered an army of 6,000 Cornishmen who declared him Richard IV. Capturing the city of Exeter his army then advanced into Somerset.
However, upon hearing that government troops were gathering he deserted his own men and was captured at Beaulieu Abbey in Hampshire.
Paraded through the streets of London to much derision, Warbeck was imprisoned in the Tower.
In 1499 he and Edward Earl of Warwick attempted to escape.
Henry had them executed.
Just as an aside, I have previously dismissed henry’s role in the murder of the princes in the tower.
Yet, he was more than happy to lock up two potential claimants in the tower and then execute them, so maybe….I’ll leave than one with you!
Still there remained one Yorkist to threaten him.
Edmund de la Pole, the Earl of Suffolk, and younger brother of John, Earl of Lincoln.
Unlike Warbeck or Simnel he was definitely a legitimate claimant - arguably with as strong a claim to the throne than Henry himself.
After Bosworth he had sworn allegiance to Henry but…well Henry was wary and tried to keep Edmund at court.
In 1501 he left England without Royal permission.
He was aided in this venture by James Tyrrell - remember him, the potential murderer of the princes in the tower. For this action(the escape not the princes) Tyrrel was executed.
He made his way to Austria, where the Emperor, Maximilian I acknowledged him as the Yorkist pretender but refused to fund any rebellion. Edmund continued to tour Europe seeking support.
In 1506 he was en-route to Spain when his ship was blown off course…ending up in England.
Henry could not believe his good luck!
The only living Yorkist claimant was placed under lock & key at thew Tower of London.
Finally Henry could rest assured that he was safe.
And with a son ready to succeed him, the Tudor dynasty would survive.
The Wars of The Roses were one of the bloodiest periods in English history.
In a 30 year period, there were 17 battles costing over 45,000 lives.
As you may have worked out by now, it was not about the counties of Yorkshire & Lancashire going to war with each other (despite what locals proudly say!).
The Wars of the Roses, as a name, is a misnomer.
The Red Rose and the White rose had been used by Dukes of Lancaster and York respectively over the 200 years. Whilst they were emblems they were not universally used throughout these dynastic wars that we have been talking about.
Whilst the White Rose was a symbol used by the Yorkists. It was not the only one nor was it the main one - Edward IV had the Sun in Splendour, Richard had the wild boar.
The red rose of Lancashire seems to have even less credibility.
If Henry Tudor was the champion of the house of Lancaster at Bosworth why was he fighting under the red dragon of Wales? Where was the red rose?
The Tudor Rose - a red rose with a white inner leaf is said to combine the Houses of York & Lancaster. Yet the idea that the two houses and their armies fought under these flags is a myth.
The myth of the two roses coming together to form a new dynasty, was a powerful and useful narrative for one man…Henry Tudor.
His dynasty was both new but drew upon old lineage from the lines of Edward III.
He was the master propagandist on behalf of his new dynasty…and we’ve seen that he had to be.
The myth started by Henry gained traction when another Tudor propagandist got his hands on it; William Shakespeare.
In his play Henry VI written just over 100 years after the battle of Bosworth he portrayed the sides each picking a rose as their emblem. And such is the power of the Baird that these emblems stuck.
And it was never referred to as “The Wars of The Roses” until this title was used by the novelist Sir Walter Scot in the early 19th century.
The wars of the roses remain a misunderstood and, in many cases, forgotten part of England’s story. But it was that moment in England’s story when the medieval age came to an end.
There was a clear divide between the middle ages and the Tudors.
In many ways the Tudors seem familiar to us, whereas the medieval era seems far, far away.
And yet, what a story.
I hope you have enjoyed it; I have certainly enjoyed researching it.
You couldn’t write a twisting, turning story like it…although someone did try. The Wars of the Roses were the inspiration for George Martin’s “Song of Ice & Fire” stories - better known as “Game of Thrones”
When Henry died in 1509, he was succeeded by his son Henry VIII.
It was the first successful handover from a king to an adult son in 100 years.
In 2012, an excavation in a public car park (the site of the Greyfrairs friary) in Leicester, a skeleton was discovered. DNA analysis proved that it was the body of Richard III. His body now lies in Leicester Cathedral.
The last Yorkist claimant, Edmund de la Pole, was not pardoned upon Henry VIII’s ascension to the throne. He remained in the Tower of London where, 4 years later he was beheaded. Henry VIII was not leaving anything to chance.
Indeed it has been argued that the fear of dynastic in-fighting that resulted in the Wars of the Roses drove Henry VIII in his desire to have an undisputed heir. It has been argued that his fear of returning to the chaos of the Yorkists & Lancastrians had as much to do with his divorce from Katherine of Aragon as any desire to break with Rome.
Lambert Simnel continued to work in the Royal kitchens and ultimately became a falconer. It is believed that he had at least one child bearing the Simnel name and died sometime between 1525-1535.
The Lord Thomas Stanley - the husband of Margaret Beaufort and great survivor of the Wars of the Roses was made the Earl of Derby. His descendants continue to hold that title to this day - we are currently on the 19th Earl.
The 12th Earl was a keen horserace who established a race meeting that bears his name - The Derby.
The Stanleys continue to have significant interest in Lancashire and the city of Liverpool.
Everton & Liverpool football grounds are separated by Stanley Park.
In 1914, the 17th Earl of derby organised one of the most successful recruitment campaigns in the First World War, when over 2 days he convinced 1,500 Liverpudlians to join up in two pals battalions.
The Woodville’s & Grays became loyal servants of the Tudors.
Elizabeth Woodville’s sister, Catherine married Henry’s uncle, Jasper Tudor.
Thomas Gray, marquis of Dorset’s grandson married Henry VII’s granddaughter.
They had a daughter, Lady Jane Gray.
Elizabeth Woodville was treated with the dignity reserved for a dowager queen for the rest of her life.
She was present at the birth of her grandson (the future Henry VIII) and spent the last 5 years in Bermondsey Abbey, in London.
She died in 1492 and was buried close to her husband, King Edward IV, in St. George’s Chapel, Windsor Castle.
Henry and Elizabeth of York were married for 17 years.
She bore 7 children. Two daughters became Queens of Scotland and France respectively, whilst her son became King Henry VIII of England’s.
In 1503 she gave birth to a daughter, Katherine, who died within days. Just a few days later, Elizabeth died of an infection at the age of 37.
Margaret Beaufort outlived her son by 2 months.
Her last key role was ensuring the smooth transition of power to her grandson and helping 18-year old Henry VIII, chose his first privy council.
She is buried in Westminster Abbey.
The Tudors were to reign for the next 100 years and, to this date, are the most famous and studied Royal house in English history. Their story is every bit as exciting, intriguing and interesting as the Wars of the Roses but that, as they say, is for another talk.