The History Chap Podcast
The History Chap Podcast
8. The Birth of Scotland & Wales
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
As you will have discovered from previous episodes, once there wasn't a country called England. Nor were there countries called Wales or Scotland either.
Just like England, the countries were divided into a series of squabbling kingdoms.
This is the story of how they finally unified into the countries we know today.
Join my Supporter's Club
Our story ends in 1063 when all three, Scotland, Wales and England are, after hundreds of years, finally unified into their respective nations.
Three years later, the Normans will conquer England and Britain will never be the same again.
So join me as I explore the intriguing story of Wales in this period - it's the story od Rodri Mawr (the Great), Hywel Da (whose law codes survived the English invasions) and Gruffudd ap Llewelyn (the only man the English ever recognised as King of all of Wales.)
Then we will travel north to see how the Picts, the Brythonic kingdom of Strathclyde and the Irish Celts of Dal Riata start to be brought together by Kenneth Mac Alpin.
We finish as one of Kenneth's descendants, Duncan, is overthrown by MacBeth (yes, THAT MacBeth!) before, in turn, being killed by Duncan's son, Malcolm Canmore.
8: The Birth of Scotland & Wales
Just as once upon a time there was no country called England, there was also no country called Scotland…or Wales for that matter.
Both the people in what we now know as Scotland and Wales have appeared briefly in our story of Britain (& the birth of England) but what had actually being going on in these areas?
It’s about time that we look at both of these areas of Britain in a bit more detail.
This is the story of the Birth of Scotland & the Princes of Wales.
Let’s talk about Wales first.
The area that we now call Wales was the area in the west of Britain where the Romano-British culture held out as the Anglo Saxons advanced after their arrival in the mid 5th century.
Wales was home to the Welsh….the name that the Anglo Saxons gave these people and it meant, somewhat ironically, “foreigners”.
The people called themselves by another name…”Cymru” or compatriots.
For nearly 150 years these Cymru or compatriots formed a a series of Brythonic kingdom unbroken up the west of Britain from Cornwall up through the Severn Valley and the West Midlands, and onto the Hen Ogledd or Old North - the kingdoms of Elmet in the Peak District, Rheged in modern day Cumbria (a word with the same roots as the Cymru of Wales) and Strathclyde and Gododdin in modern day lowland Scotland (more of them later).
Even modern-day Wales was split into a variety of kingdoms in particular Gwynedd in the north (whose royal family were to reign from the departure of the Romans right through to medieval England), Powys in the centre (probably extending eastwards to modern day Shrewsbury) and Dyfed in the south west - which seems to have been an extension of pre-Roman Demetae tribe with later Irish settlers).
In the south east of Wales were the smaller kingdoms of Gwent and Morgannwg.
For the next 600 years these compatriots, Welsh or Brythonic Britons fought a never ending battle with the Anglo Saxons and their ever-westward creep.
By 577 the Saxons of Wessex had defeated several minor British kings in the Bath / Gloucestershire are capturing the old Roman cities of Cirencester, Gloucester and Bath (itself), reaching the Severn estuary and breaking the land link between the Cornish of Dunmonia and their Brythonic cousins to the north.
And then in 616 the Anglian armies of Northumbria met the army of Powys at Chester.
200 monks came from the nearby monastery at Bangor on Dee to pray from a Christian victory over the pagan Northumbrians.
The Northumbrian king, Aethelfrith, had all 200 killed before the battle where he destroyed the Welsh army, seized Chester and broke the land link between the Welsh and Hen Ogledd (The Old North).
Oh, and if you think you think Aethelfrith of Northumbria rings a bell. He was the king that Raedwald of East Anglia (the king probably buried at Sutton Hoo) defeated at the River Idle in Talk 4 (the Anglo Saxon Kingdoms).
You might also recall that just 30 years later, the Britons had their greatest chance to reverse this Anglo Saxon invasion.
In 633 the king of Gwynedd, Cadwallon, made and literally unholy alliance with the pagan king of Mercia (Penda) and smashed the Northumbrian army at the battle of Hatfield Chase.
Cadwallon then ravaged Northumbria, but before he could reverse the Anglo Saxon advance forever, he in turn was defeated and killed by the new King of Northumbria, Oswald at the battle of Heavensfield.
And with Cadwallon’s defeat the high tide of the British fight-back receded.
Never again would they achieve such a stunning victory or advance that far east.
Modern day Wales continued in their time honoured way of minor kingdoms trying to gain advantage over each other, fighting the Saxons (now, principally the kingdom of Mercia) and countering viking raids.
Unlike England or Scotland, there seemed no desire for a Project Wales.
And then in the middle of the 9th century out of the mountains of Snowdonia came a king of Gwynedd who would change all of that.
Rodri Mawr or Rodri the Great.
In 856 he defeated a Dublin-Viking invasion on the island of Anglesey.
Do you remember Anglesey from episode 2 - back at the time of the Roman conquest it had been the druidical centre of Britain.
With his victory over the Norse Rodri now took over Powys.
In 872 he annexed the small kingdom of Ceredigion.
To his east the vikings had decimated the Anglo Saxon kingdoms and the king of Wessex, was holding on for dear life.
Meanwhile Rodri Mawr, the Great (conqueror of the vikings) controlled two-thirds of Wales.
Maybe there would suddenly be a united Wales long before there was a united England (let alone Scotland…and you are going to hear all about them in a little while).
Following the various lines of succession through all these Welsh kingdoms is complicated…not just because of the pronunciations but because the royal lines intermarried meaning someone who came from one kingdom ended up, through their own right not conquest, ruling another kingdom.
A case in point is one of Rodri Mawr’s grandsons; Hywel Da (or Hywell the Good).
In the early 900’s he inherited the throne of a kingdom in the south west of Wales and by 910 had absorbed the kingdom of Dyfed, forming a new kingdom - Deheubarth.
Wales was effectively divided by Hywel in the south and the kingdom of Gwynedd in the north ruled by Idwal.
In 927 Hywel had submitted to King Athelstan of England.
Probably had more to do with using English might as a counter-balance to his rival Idwal of Gwynedd rather than any form of real subservience to the Anglo Saxons.
In fact Hywel and Athelstan were friendly enough that the English king allowed Hywell to use the royal mint in Chester to produce his own silver pennies.
Hywel produced the first law code for Wales - the Laws of Hywel Da.
These laws are interesting in that they gave legal stars to women and children - something absent from the law books of England.
The Laws of Hywel Da remained the main laws governing Wales for the next 600 years until a new law code was established by a descendant of another Welsh family - Henry VIII.
If Hywel was on accommodating terms with the English, Idwal certainly wasn’t.
He saw himself as a successor to Cadwallon and in 942 he launched an attack on the English.
He faired about as well as every Welsh ruler since Cadwallon….he was killed.
Hywel spotted an opportunity and successfully invaded Gwynedd driving out Idwal’s sons.
By the time Hywel died he ruled all of the Wales except for Morgannwg in the south east.
Once more Wales broke back into a variety of kingdoms all connected by blood.
It wasn’t until 90 years later than another attempt to unify Wales gained traction.
This time under Gruffudd ap Llewelyn, king of Gwynedd.
In 1039 he had reasserted Welsh (or at least Gwynedd’s) independence with a victory over the English at Welshpool and with that victory also gained control over Powys.
In 1055 he annexed Deheubarth in the south west and a year later he gained control of Morgannwg.
He then marched into England and at Hereford defeated the local Fryrd led by a Norman supporter of King Edward the Confessor - Earl Ralph. He then laid late to the town.
The following year the Bishop of Hereford invaded Wales seeking revenge…instead at a battle at Glasbury, on the River Wye, he was killed by Gruffudd and his seasoned warriors.
Gruffudd ap Llewelyn was recognised by the English as King of Wales.
The only man ever so-recognised by the English.
Gruffudd had achieved what no Welsh leader had done before and would never do again, he was king over all of Wales.
By 1063, however, Gruffudd had antagonised the English once too often and a combined sea and land attack Harold and Tostig Godwinson forced Gruffudd to seek safety in the mountains of Snowdonia.
There he was killed by one of his own men.
And so ended Wales’s brief moment of being a unified kingdom.
As a foot note, Gruffudd’s widow, an English noblewoman from Mercia was to marry Harold Godwinson when he became king of England a few years later.
Let’s now move to the north of this island called Britain (Scotland).
Before the Roman invasion Britain was made up of a variety of tribes (30 in total).
They all spoke a common Brythonic language.
The Roman invasion and the construction of Hadrian’s Wall however, broke the island in two.
Those tribes to the south of the Wall were, to one extent or another slowly Romanised.
Those above the wall but below the Clyde / Forth estuaries (where the Antonine Wall had been established) were outside the empire but but trading and cultural links with the tribes to the south.
Whilst the 5 tribes in the very north (in particular the Caledonii) were left way outside the orbit of Rome.
Over the next 300 years these northern tribes re-formed themselves into a variety of smaller kingdoms they were given the collective name - Picts (meaning painted people - probably because of the blue woad they used to paint their bodies).
The Picts were not one political entity but more a variety of groups with a common language and culture.
Rather like the Bratewaldas of the Anglo Saxons, the Picts tended to have one “high king” whom the others acknowledged whilst fiercely protecting their own independence.
It was these Picts who started to raid beyond the wall into the Roman province of Britannia in the twilight days of the Empire.
The end of the Roman Empire in Britain was marked by a fragmentation of the Romano-British or Brythonic people into a variety of minor kingdoms (as we discussed just now with regard to Wales) and the influx of Germanic invaders cum settlers (the Anglo Saxons).
At this moment in time, around 500 AD, what we now call Scotland was actually occupied by three distinct groups.
The Picts in the far north.
The area further south, on either side of the wall, came to be known as Hen Ogledd“The Old North” - speaking a language that was akin to modern-day Welsh.
Into this loose coalition fell the kingdoms of Rheged (in what is now Cumbria), Gododdin who were basically the old pre-Roman Votadini tribe (around modern-day Edinburgh) and Strathclyde (running from the Clyde down to Rheged).
And muscling their way in to the west were Irish invader/settlers from across the sea - The Scotti - who formed the Gaelic speaking kingdom of Dal Riata.
It was the kings of Dal Riata, who welcomed their fellow Irish christian missionaries to the shores of Scotland.
King Aidan allowed St. Columba to establish a monastery on the island of Iona.
These missionaries moved out into Pictland and down into the Anglian kingdoms of Bernicia (shortly to become Northumbria) converting the pagans and establishing the Celtic Church, rather than the Roman one, as the predominant church in the north of Britain.
The Celtic church differed from Rome in the role of bishops (basically in the Roman church that acted like princes and lived in Bishop’s Palaces) whereas the Celtic church was centred on monasteries with the Abbots holding far more power than bishops.
The humble missionary style of the Celtic church, along with less insistence on celibacy was most certainly at odds with the more Imperial style of Roman Christianity.
The real big “bug bear” was the difference in the way the monks cut their hair (I kid you not) and the date of Easter.
If you remember from my talk on the Anglo Saxon Kingdoms (talk 4) this all came to a head (pardon the pun) when the King of Northumbria called the two sides together at the Synod of Whitby in 664 and found in favour of Rome.
Thereafter, the Celtic church went into decline and Roman Catholicism doctrine took over in Britain.
Speaking of the Anglo Saxons and in particular Northumbria they were making advances into the north.
In 603, less than 200 years after the Anglian Bernicians defeated King Aidan of Dal Riata at the battle of Degsastan and by 680 the Northumbrian’s (as they were now called) had swallowed up Gododdin and their fortress rock at Edinburgh.
So we had Anglo Saxons controlling the south east of Scotland - which they would continue to do until about 950 (100 years before the Norman invasion of England).
Five years later, the Northumbrians invaded the land of the Picts.
The Pictish king, Bridei fell back before them, drawing the Northumbrians deeper and deeper into the hills and glens of the Highlands.
And at an unidentified place called Nechtansmere he sprung his trap.
The Picts won a resounding victory, wiping out most of the Northumbrian army including their king. The Northumbrians would never again come this far north.
For the next 100 years, it looked like the Picts were the power beyond Hadrians Wall successfully defeating Dal Riata and receiving the submission of Strathclyde.
But in the late 700’s Project Scotland, was interrupted.
And just like Project England, it was interrupted from across the North Sea.
In 795, just two years after Vikings had struck the Northumbrian monastery at Lindisfarne, they arrived at Iona.
The monastery at Iona, home of St. Columba, was raided three times in the next 9 years.
In the last attack in 806, 68 monks were massacred.
They had enough.
By the time the Vikings next arrived in 825, they found that the monks (and treasures that remained) had relocated to Kells in Ireland.
Just like England to the south, the initial raids became something more permanent. The Norse settled in the Western Isles, (which they ruled until the mid-1200’s) Caithness & Sutherland in the far north, and most famously in Orkney in Shetland.
In fact the Scandinavians remained in control of Orkney & Shetland until the mid 15th century. That’s right, the Tudors were on the throne of England before the descendants of the vikings finally gave up their hold.
And just like England, the Viking impact eventually helped shape a new nation - Scotland.
The Vikings successfully captured the Strathclyde stronghold of Dumbarton, fatally peaking the Brythonic kingdom.
Meanwhile, the constant raiding in the north & along the east coast weakened the Picts.
The Scots of Dal Riata, on the west, were slightly less exposed and consequently their influence rose as a by-product of the Viking raids.
Moreover, the Gaelic language of the Celtic Church meant that for many Picts Gaelic speaking Dal Riata was not quite as alien as it used to be.
The year 839 was a turning point.
The Scots and the Picts united against a viking invasion.
In the subsequent battle, the vikings were victorious and the kings of both the Picts and Dal Riada were killed.
It could have been a disaster but from the ensuing power vacuum in both kingdoms a claimant came forward to fill both vacancies.
Kenneth Mac Alpin.
Kenneth emerged as the king of Dal Riata and within 10 years of that Viking victory he had added Pictland to his domain. For the first time all of Scotland north of the Clyde & Forth was ruled by one king.
His family, The House of Alpin were to rule for the next 200 years.
Rather like in England, where Wessex and Mercia were still seen as separate entities despite having the same ruler, the same was true in the north.
Kenneth’s successors - his brother and his nephew were called kings of Dal Riata and kings of the Picts.
Finally, his great nephew, Domnall - was see as king of a united kingdom - not Scotland but Alba.
It took over 100 years, for the Kingdom to become Scotland.
Remember that the Picts had been more like an alliance rather than one centralised power?
Well, those sub-kings were given new titles - Mormaers - and these Mormaers of Athol, Angus and Moray were powerful players who weren’t going to be bossed around by some new fangled king of Alba or Scotland.
As we will find out later.
But first, there was a new power to contend with to the south.
If you remember from my last talk, it was about this time that England finally became a political entity under Athelstan.
In fact Athelstan was not just after English unity but dominance over the whole of the island.
Eventually to counter this, King Constantine II of Scotland formed a grand alliance with Strathclyde and the Viking Dublins and invaded England only to meet with complete disaster at the battle of Brunanburgh in 937.
Maybe it is a testament to Constantine that he had build up a kingdom robust enough to survive such a calamitous defeat (and for his own hold on power to survive too.)
In 1005 when Kenneth Mac Alpin’s great-great-great grandson, Malcolm II ascended the throne, was not the country we know on a map today. The south west (Strathclyde) was still an independent kingdom, the south east (Lothian) was controlled by the Northumbrians or English, and the Vikings controlled Western Isles and Orkney & Shetland.
But that was about to change.
At the same time that Aethelraed the Unready was fighting desperately to retain his throne in England against Danish invaders, Malcolm defeated the English at Carham on the River Tweed and annexed Lothian into Scotland.
From now on, Edinburgh would be Scottish.
Malcolm had 2 grandsons.
Duncan became King upon Malcolm’s death.
But he ended up at war with other grandson, the Mormaer of Moray.
Remember, that I said that the Mormaer’s were powerful semi-independent rulers in their own right?
Well, that proved to be the case the Mormaer of Moray obviously did something to displease Duncan and he marched into Moray only to end up being defeated and killed by his half-brother in battle.
The half-brother now became king….his name was MacBeth.
Eventually, in 1054 Macbeth was driven from the throne by Duncan’s son, Malcolm III, with English assistance. Macbeth and Malcolm continued to fight until 1058 when MacBeth was killed and shortly afterwards his son.
Malcolm would now reign unopposed for the next 35 years.
Malcom, know as “Canmore” (or Great Chief) now consolidated Scotland by invading Strathclyde.
He captured their stronghold of Carlisle whilst the south of the kingdom (modern day Cumbria - without Carlisle) was annexed by the English.
By 1063 Scotland as we now know had finally been born.
Malcolm Canmore married the king of England, Edward the Confessor relative - Margaret of Wessex - creating a blood bond between the royal houses of England and Scotland for the first time.
In 1063 we had a moment in British history where England, Scotland and Wales had all separately unified as independent countries. It would never happen again.
Because 3 years later everything would change for Wales, Scotland and especially for England…3 years later it was 1066.