The History Chap Podcast
The History Chap Podcast
3. The Dark Ages
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In 410 the desperate citizens of the Roman province of Britannia sent the Emperor a plea for help against increasing attacks from pirates and the Picts from beyond Hadrians Wall.
The Emperor, Honorius sent them a simple reply which basically said "You are on your own."
Britain descended into chaos - "The Dark Ages"
The urban sophistication of the Roman years was abandoned, the land was ruled by warlords.
And into this chaos arrived a group of invaders turned settlers - the Anglo Saxons.
This is the story of how they tried to establish themselves on the island and how the locals fought back. It is the story of legendary warriors like King Arthur and real warriors like Urien of Rheged.
Legends and truths end up mixed together in "The Dark Ages."
Join my Supporter's Club
3. The Dark Ages
At the end of my last talk, “Boudicca & The Romans” a series of Roman military commanders in Britain had attempted to seize power in the Empire and had denuded Britain of her garrison in their various bids to wear the purple.
Naked and facing increased attacks from the Picts across Hadrian’s Wall and across the seas from Irish and Saxon (German) pirates, the leading citizens appeared to Rome for assistance.
In 410 the Emperor Honorius sent them a simple message:
“The Cantons should take steps to defend themselves”
Britain had effectively been cast out of the Roman Empire.
What would happen next?
Well, the answer is that we are not entirely sure exactly what did happen.
We do know that Britain descended into chaos.
New settlers arrived who would fundamentally change the face of the island.
These new settlers were pagans, who kept no written records, and shunned the urban living of the Romano-British.Instead of stone villas with tiled floors, central heating and tiled roofs, they dwelt in simple wooden and thatch huts.
Compared to the luxury of sophistication that had gone before, this was a step backwards.
It was also a step into the anarchy of petty warlords and invasion.
These were dark days the lost Roman province of Britannia.
And just to add to those bleak, black days, a lack of written records mean that no one, to this day, really knows what happened for nearly 200 years.
Welcome to “The Dark Ages.”
Just because the Romans had left Britain, it didn’t mean that Roman life suddenly disappeared.
And just because they were no longer a Roman province didn’t suddenly make Britannia less attractive to those raiders.
In fact, a wealthy country with no military protection was an ideal target for a raiding Pict from modern-day Scotland or a pirate.
The raids continued.
As I said previously, Britain was being raided by three distinct groups.
Saxon pirates from Frisia (Basically the coastline from modern day Netherlands through north west Germany to approximately the modern-day border between Germany & Denmark).
They raided Britain along its eastern and souther seaboards.
Next were the the old tribes from the far north of Britain, who had slowly come together in a loose alliance - the Picts (which translates as “The Painted Ones”.
They swept over the undefended Hadrian’s Wall into the former Roman province.
Finally, there were pirates from Ireland who were raiding the western seaboards searching for booty and slaves.
It was this last group who sometime around the end of Roman rule landed and abducted a young man called Patricius.
We don’t know precisely when this occurred nor where. Theories abound that it was somewhere in Wales, but others suggest on the English side of the Severn estuary (modern day Gloucestershire) whilst there is also an argument for modern-Day Cumbria (near Carlisle).
Escaping after 6 years in slavery he returned to Britain only to then journey back to Ireland to convert the locals to Christianity…we know him as St. Patrick.
Meanwhile how were the Britons going to cope outside the Roman Empire whilst facing these threats?
Without any central control Britain fell into fragmented power blocks - effectively ruled by warlords. Some styled themselves kings.
Some of these warlords might have been former-imperial officials, others it seems were continuations of the old elites who had ruled in pre-Roman days.
By 441/42 , just 30 years after the legions had left, a Gaulish chronicler recorded that Britain was “falling into the power of the Saxons.”
Unfortunately he doesn’t bother to record how much of Britain had fallen nor whether the Saxons were raiders or settlers.
Within the decade a “High King” of the British seems to have emerged by the name of Vortigern.
His power-base was probably in the east of the island, maybe in Kent.
And in 449, Vortigern made a fatal decision.
He invited a group of Saxons to settle in the east in return for helping the Britons fight against the Picts.
What happened next is not easily established.
Because of the lack of written records, this whole period ends up with is a miso-mash of real events, mixed with myths and legends.
The best accounts that we have are from Gildas, a 6th century monk based in Wales who records various events in his “On the Ruin and Conquest of Britain.”
The Venerable Bede who wrote his “Ecclesiastical History of the English People” in the early 700’s.
About 100 years after Bede, we have the “Historia Brittonum” written by a Welsh monk and finally we have the Anglo-Saxon Chronicles written from the late 9th century.
So no eye witness accounts and a lot of historical “facts” which smell more of myth & legend.
Indeed the early parts of the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle - the arrival of the Angles & Saxons in Britain reads more like the ancient sagas or poems.
Not only are they written long after the events but they had biases in their stories.
For a start, Gildas’s chronicle “On the Ruin & Conquest of Britain” was a religious condemnation of the behaviours of the British kings in Wales in the mid 6th century.
He was less concerned about facts and more concerned about lambasting the rulers of his day.
Likewise, the Anglo Saxon chronicle is a propaganda effort in support of Alfred The Great and the royal house of Wessex. So again the events that are re-told from early Anglo Saxon history have a wiff of legend & myth about them.
But they are all we have and so, as we talk about Britain in the Dark Ages, I will refer to these sources.
Anyway, back to Vortigern.
According to Gildas, two Saxon brothers named Hengist & Horsa arrived in Kent to provide the muscle against the Picts.
Once again it was not recorded if this was Vortigern acting alone or whether he was merely the frontman for a coalition of fellow warlords.
The practise of using “barbarians”to defend the borders had a long history elsewhere in the Roman Empire and it seems that the Romano-Britons were simply copying this practise.
But just like elsewhere in the empire there was a danger.
And so it turned out in Britain.
The Saxons either decided that it would be a lot more profitable to go freelance or the Roman-British refused to pay what had been agreed.
Either way, the Saxons turned on their masters.
According to traditional history, they invited friends, families and whole communities to cross the North Sea in a mass invasion. Three distinct groups of invaders arrived - the Saxons, the Angles and the Jutes and according to Gildas they seized the land and pursued the people into Wales & Cornwall.
In 477, Ella and his 3 sons established the kingdom of the South Saxons (or Sussex).
In 495, Cerdic and Cynric had founded Wessex (the west saxons)
Meanwhile, in the north east, Ida had taken over the old kingdom of Bernicia (northumbria)
The Jutes adopted the ancient British name for their kingdom in south east Britain - Cantiaci (or Kent).
Having emptied the land by a Dark Age form of ethnic cleansing they say up their own Anglo-Saxon kingdoms.
But the Britons fought back.
Enter King Arthur.
Geoffrey of Monmouth writing his “The History of the Kings of Britain” in 1136 is the main English source for the King Arthur story.
Geoffrey who was not just writing long after the events but was regarded, even in his own time, as a liar is not our most reliable source.
The fact that he claims that the Ancient Britons were descended from the Trojans makes you suspicious of many of the other stories that he presents as fact….like, for instance, King Arthur.
It was Geoffrey of Monmouth who really put King Arthur on the map.
Within 100 years the story was being recited (as a truth) all over Europe and being embellished as it went.
By the time the story had travelled through France, Lancelot and the Holy Grail had been added.
According to this story King Arthur was a high king of Britain, who took the war to the Saxon invaders.
He fought 12 great battles, culminating in a massive victory at Badon, where he single handily killed 960 men.
But Geoffrey was drawing upon a character who was mentioned in both the Historic Brittonum (written by the Welsh monk in the 850’s) and also the Welsh Annals written about 100 years later.
The Welsh annals, say Arthur was killed in battle somewhere in northern England in around 537.
But, and it is a big BUT, neither Gildas, Bede or the Anglo Saxon chronicle mention King Arthur.
And Gildas was the closest to the period that Arthur supposedly lived.
So did Arthur exist - we really don’t know.
It could be a complete myth.
Or he could be based upon a real character or an amalgamation of real characters, in which Arthur as the sum of the whole is greater than the individual parts.
Or maybe he did exist, in which case it is strange that the historian closest to this period, Gildas doesn’t mention him. Especially as he is castigating the present day rulers for letting Britain go to the dogs. Surely if Arthur was real then Gildas would have been tempted to write something on the lines of: “you lot are a disgrace and not a patch on a proper king like Arthur”
Gildas does however, mention another warrior from roughly the same time period…Ambrosius Aurelianus.
Not only does Ambrosius have a Roman-British name but Gildas also wrote that his family had worn the purple - in other word they had held senior imperial positions in the Roman province of Britannia.
Interestingly, he is one of the very few British leaders that Gildas does mention by name.
Having said that, even his accounts of Ambrosius are pretty scant.
Ambrosius Aurelianus does make it into Geoffrey of Monmouth’s Arthurian story where he appears as King Arthur’s uncle.
It seems that he might have ruled, or been the paramount ruler, in the west of Britain.
Unlike the Arthurian legends, Gildas is more sanguine about Ambrosius’s military feats.
Sometimes he beat the saxons and sometimes he lost.
Both Gildas & Bede imply that it was Ambrosius who was victorious at Badon.
Unfortunately neither mentions any of those actually present. So we are left in the dark.
In fact, we don’t even know where the Battle of Badon was fought, although the strongest school of though places it in the area of Amesbury, close to Stonehenge.
But it seems that Baddon was fought around the year 500 and was so crushing a victory that it put a stop to Saxon advances for over 30 years.
So whoever, was in charge it was a significant win for the Romano-British.
Whilst Arthur seems to be the stuff of legend, there is evidence of another British warrior leader - Urien of Rheged.
In the late 500’s Urien allied with the other kings of the Old North to attack King Ida, the Angle king of Bernicia.
They defeated the Bernicians at the battle of Gwen Ystrat (Gwen Valley), killed one of Ida’s sons in another battle near the headwaters of the River Tees and besieged Ida on the island of Lindisfarne.
For the first time since Badon the British were about to deliver a crushing military defeat to the Anglo Saxons.
Maybe after all these years, this was the turning point.
And then Urien was assassinated by a kinsman who was jealous of his success and wanted some glory for himself.
Wrong! Ida stormed out of his island fortress, smashed the armies of the Old North alliance.
And Urien of Rheged was consigned to a footnote of history (and a role in later Arthurian legends).
History has been told in a very simplistic way.
In the east were the Anglo Saxons and in the west were the British or Welsh.
Each group was united and each of their areas.
But that was far from the case.
For instance, there was the area called Hen Ogledd, the Old North.
A series of Brythonic speaking kingdoms stretching from Lancashire up into Cumbria and onwards into modern day Scotland.
In South Yorkshire and the Peak District we had the kingdom of Elmet.
In south west Scotland, the Kingdom of Strathclyde.
In modern day Lothian, the kingdom of Gododdin.
And in Cumbria the kingdom of Rheged.
Rheged seemed to have been centred around Carlisle and was created around the time of the Roman departure by a local military commander - Coel Hen. Translated from Brythonic that is Cole the Old or…and you will love this one…Old King Cole.
Strathclyde remained an independent Brythonic kingdom until just before the Norman Conquest, when it was absorbed into the new kingdom of Scotland. More of that in another talk.
Likewise, what we now call Wales was just the western part of the Brythonic speaking Britannia and was split between various factions - Gwynedd (which legend has was founded by warriors from northern Britain) as well as Powys amongst others.
To their east around modern day Shrewsbury was the kingdom or tribe of Pengwern.
Meanwhile in the South West was the kingdom of Dunmonia, based upon the old pre-Roman tribe by the same name.
The Tribal Hideage (a document written somewhere between the 7th- 9th centuries) in other words at least 200 years after the arrival of the Saxons identifies 75 tribes or kingdoms in Britain,
They range from Mercia to the South Saxons to smaller kingdoms such as Elmet and the Spalda in south Lincolnshire and the Hicca, who seemed to be a British group still going strong around the modern day town of Hitchin in Hertfordshire.
We don’t know the boundaries or these different groups but it is clear evidence that there were not 7 Anglo Saxon kingdoms from the outset, whatever the Anglo Saxon Chronicles might like to suggest.
Nor is it clear that Gildas’s assertion that the Saxons wiped out “our People” as he calls them is true.
The Gildas view of this period of British history became the prevailing view until the last 100 years and is still the easy option taught in schools.
And it is easy to see why.
Gildas is the only contemporary source and if he says everyone was wiped out them must have been.
It is true that the ever westward shift brought the Saxons of Wessex and the Britons of Dumnonia into conflict.
In 577, King Ceawlin of Wessex defeated the army of Dumnonia at the battle of Deorham and cut the south west peninsular off from their Celtic brethren in Wales.
By 658 the Britons had been driven back to the River Parrett in Somerset and by 700 it seems that they had lost control of Exeter.
Many of the Britons from Dumnonia upped sticks and sailed over to France, settling in the area that bears their name to this day - Brittany.
One of the delicious ironies of history is that in 1066 the left win of William The Conqueror’s army at Hastings was made up of Bretons.
So there would have been descendants of the Dumnonia fighting the Saxons all over again…
Similarly a push west by the Northumbrians would ultimately split the kingdoms of Hen Ogledd (the Old North) from their Welsh cousins.
By 730 Rheged had been absorbed into the Anglian kingdom of Northumbria.
However, it seems that King Oswiu of Northumbria was married to a princess from Rheged, so maybe the takeover was more dynastic and peaceful than the traditional stories that the only way the Anglo Saxons moved across England was by war and conquest.
But don’t forget that he was writing over 100 years after the initial arrival of the Saxons and he was writing from the safety of Wales. Did he really know what had happened to the British in say Somerset or Hertfordshire?
It has only been in the last 100 years that archeological and then DNA evidence has cast a different light.
This evidence suggests that the story of Britain is a bit more complex and intriguing than a simple ethnic cleansing.
Put simply, there is evidence of Saxon domination in the very east - Kent, East Anglia, modern day Hampshire and the Thames Valley.
But the further west you go, the DNA records from skeletons is more interesting.
Those people, who we call Anglo Saxons, have a lot of British blood running in their veins - especially in the midlands.
Indeed the word Mercia roughly translates as the border people.
So what really happened during the dark ages.
There was certainly conflict but how could an invasion by Saxon warriors and their families have wiped out 2 million people.
The story is more intriguing than simple ethnic cleansing.
Remember why, according to Gildas, the Saxons were here in the first place.
They came as hired muscle and they then rebelled.
So what we have is a group of warriors taking control.
Whilst they very well might have then sent messages back to their families to join them, they could also have taken local wives.
Possibly wives of the local elites whom they had just displaced.
So what we may have is a new ruling elite that was actually mixed Germanic and British.
With a new Germanic speaking, Wodin worshipping elite, what would those Brits who had stuck around have done?
It is very likely that a form of Elite Dominance could have taken place.
If your new lord whom you worked for spoke some Germanic language it was essential for your survival that you learnt that language - otherwise how would you ask for a job or understand the orders he was giving you.
And flip that on itsitsits head. Why would the boss learn the language of his workers?
Sounds a bit far fetched?
During the later British Empire, How many British settlers in Kenya or Rhodesia learnt the local languages. But what is the language of commerce in Kenya and Zimbabwe? English.
So what couldn’t a similar thing have happened back in Britain itself during the Dark Ages?
Some historians have also argued that the Anglo Saxon men practised a form of sexual apartheid, taking several local British women as concubines.
Their children would have had Saxon and British DNA.
Moreover, if the war lord had grabbed all the women, how did British men procreate? They didn’t.
So the pure British population dwindled to be replaced by a Germanic population with some British blood in it.
There is also some evidence that during the 5th century Britain was hit by a plague which the Saxons seemed to have an immunity to but which wrecked havoc in the Romano-British population. So it is possible that some de-population occurred which both gave the Saxons the upper hand and allowed them to settle in vacated territory.
What we do know is that the Britons or as the Anglo Saxons called them “Welsh” didn’t disappear from what is now England.
In 694 King Ide of Wessex issued a law code based upon a compensation system called a Wergild.
Basically, if you harmed someone you had to pay compensation (a Wergild) based upon the person’s status or value in society. For instance killing a prince would cost you a lot more than killing a lowly farmer.
And in that law code, written nearly 150 years after Gildas, he sets a particular wergild for his Welsh subjects.
In other words, there were people who were seen as British living in Wessex long after they should have been wiped out.
The wergild put little value on being Welsh, so as a further form of elite dominance and survival for your family, there was an additional reason for a Briton to adopt Anglo Saxon ways and call himself a Saxon rather than a Welshman.
Interestingly, whilst we are on the subject of Wessex, here is a tantalising thought.
The traditional story as told by the Anglo Saxon Chronicle is that Wessex was founded by a Saxon warrior called Cerdic around 519.
In fact the current Queen can trace her lineage all the way back to Cerdic himself.
However, most scholars reckon that Cerdic is not a Germanic name but Brythonic.
In other words Cerdic was, at the very least, part British and not 100% Saxon.
Maybe Britain’s story is a little bit more complex than we were taught at school.
I find the Dark Ages a fascinating period of history - its fascinating and intriguing, its murky…
But what we do know is that new Germanic culture had arrived in the south & east of Britain and despite the best efforts of the British warlords and kings, those Anglo Saxons had not been evicted.
Join me next time as I tell the story of how their tiny tribes and power blocks would consolidate into fewer, larger kingdoms and ultimately into one Kingdom - England.
It is the story of Bretwaldas, the arrival of Christianity, one last desperate throw of the dice by the Britons, the golden age of Northumbria and of the rise of the midland kingdom of Mercia under their greatest king, Offa.