The History Chap Podcast
The History Chap Podcast
20: Elizabeth vs Mary Queen of Scots
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
This is one of those stories from British history that has fascinated people down the generations.
In a world ruled by men, two women ascend the thrones of England and Scotland.
Relatives and rivals - Elizabeth I of England and Mary Queen of Scots.
Join my Supporter's Club
When Elizabeth succeeded her sister to the English throne, she did so as a Protestant and, seen by many Catholics, as illegitimate.
They believed that she had no right to the throne and looked elsewhere for a champion.
And they didn't have to look far, Mary Queen of Scots was Elizabeth's half-cousin (once removed), the great-granddaughter of Henry VII (Henry Tudor).
Here was their replacement for Elizabeth.
In this episode we explore the undercurrents that drove these two Queens rivalry, which ultimately ended in tragedy.
20. Elizabeth v Mary Queen of Scots
When Mary I of England died in 1558, she was succeeded by her half-sister.
As Queen Elizabeth I she ranks alongside Henry VIII as the most famous Tudor monarch and in polls regularly stands as one of England’s greatest sovereigns.
The Elizabethan age saw England step onto the world stage, full of confidence and daring. Voyages of discovery to new lands, Francis Drake circumnavigating the globe, English settlers arriving in North America and new commercial ventures such as the East India Company, establish new trading routes and introduce new exotic goods to England.
It was an age of high fashion and of an explosion in theatre - Christopher Marlowe, Thomas Kidd and William Shakespeare.
And the defeat of the Spanish Armada.
And yet, whilst Elizabeth basks in this aura of England’s “golden age” if we flip the same coin over, on the other side we find her cousin (once removed), who story is far less glorious, far more poignant and full of what might have beens.
This is the story of Queen Elizabeth I and Mary Queen of Scots.
Mary was born on the 14th December 1542, at Linlithgow Castle near Edinburgh.
Her father was King James V of Scotland, the son of King James IV and his wife, Margaret Tudor.
Margaret was the daughter of Henry VII (the first of the Royal House of Tudor), and thus the older sister to Henry VIII.
James had been king of Scotland since he was about 1 year old, after his father (and Henry VIII’s brother-in-law) had invaded England in support of Scotland’s Auld Alliance with France, and had been killed at the Battle of Flodden Field.
If you thought that a one-year old king was bad news in those times, worse was to come.
James V died just 6 days after Mary was born.
Despite her age, the tiny baby princess was proclaimed Queen of Scotland (the first queen regnant in Scotland’s history - beating England by 11 years) and was crowned the following year when she was just 10 months old.
Because of her tender years, a Regency was declared until she was of age to govern in her own right.
The Regency, as we have seen in my previous talks about England, was an opportunity for powerful nobles to increase their own wealth & power.
And, just like England, this was the case now in Scotland.
But it also revealed crucial fault-lines in Scottish society and politics.
Scotland was in the throes of its own Protestant reformation.
Unlike England, where Henry had taken political control of the religious debate, up in Scotland it was more of a free-for-all.
Preachers, like John Knox, advocated a radical form of Protestantism - similar to the Puritans down in England.
Meanwhile, the young queen and her mother, Mother of Guise, were staying loyal to the Roman Catholic Church.
That split was played out by the rival fan lions as each sought control over the infant Queen.
Added to that was another layer of intrigue between the pro-English and Pro-French factions at court - the latter led by Mary of Guise.
Similar factionalism would be seen down in England at the end of the decade when Henry died and his young son, Edward VI, ascended the throne.
But at this juncture in our story, Henry VIII was still very much the King of England and his young son was just 5 years older than Mary…
And that gave Henry a plan.
A marriage between the two young royals.
Initially, Scottish negotiators accepted this treaty but when they returned to Scotland they found the parliament there far less enthusiastic.
In fact, the deal with their over-bearing southern neighbour was rejected out of hand.
And that over bearing souther neighbour, reacted in character. Henry went to war with Scotland.
This conflict, the so-called Rough Wooing was still going on when Henry died and Edward came to the throne in 1547.
England was now ruled by a king who was 9 and a half.
Their northern neighbour by a Queen, just 4 and a half.
Whether anyone in England still entertained a possible royal marriage is not clear.
What, however, was clear was that there was a war to be fought and won.
The following year, 1548, the English under Edward’s Lord Protector, Edward Seymour Duke of Somerset, advanced into Scotland and won a resounding victory at the Battle of Pinkie, near Edinburgh.
It was the last major battle fought between the nations of England and Scotland.
This English aggression had two effects in Scotland.
It strengthened the hand of the Pro-French faction, especially when France sent troops to counter the English advanced.
Secondly, and far more importantly, the Scots realised that Scotland was too dangerous for their young queen.
That very same year, Mary was packed off to her mother’s native France for safety.
She wasn’t to return to Scotland for 13 years.
Ten years later, 1558, Mary married Francis, the Dauphin of France - the heir to the French throne.
A year later, Francis succeeded to the throne.
There was Mary, aged 17, Queen in her own right of Scotland, Queen consort of France, and interestingly, with a claim to the English throne too.
By now, things had moved on in England.
Edward VI had died.
His half-sister, Mary had been and gone and now his other half-sister, Elizabeth, was Queen of England.
And so begins one of those fascinating chapters in history, when those old adversarial neighbours, Scotland and England were ruled by tow charismatic women.
I said, that Mary had a claim to the English throne and here’s how.
Her grandmother was sister to Henry VIII.
Henry had, three children from three of his 6 wives.
The king had divorced Catherine of Aragon, mother of Mary and by doing so had announced that Mary was illegitimate.
He moved on to wife number 2, Anne Boleyn. She gave birth to Elizabeth.
Anne fell foul of Henry, the marriage was annulled and she was beheaded.
As that marriage had been annulled Elizabeth was also declared illegitimate.
Finally, the longed-for make heir arrived thanks to wife number 3, Jane Seymour, who died soon after giving birth.
As Henry was now a widower he could move not to wife 4…and 5…and 6.
Crucially, Edward was considered legitimate.
Well, legitimate with one caveat, which we will come to in a moment.
Despite refusing to recognise either of his daughters as legitimate, Henry did place them in the line of succession. By Act of Parliament, Mary and Elizabeth were numbers 2 and 3 respectively, behind Edward and his heirs.
As Edward died without heirs, Mary was next in line.
Due to England’s own Protestant reformation against Catholicism, Edward had attempted to prevent Catholic Mary ascending the throne by naming his cousin-once removed (from Henry’s younger sister) his heir - Lady Jane Grey.
Despite being proclaimed Queen in London, Lady Jane’s reign lasted a full 9 days before Mary entered London.
Now with Mary dying childless after a 5 year reign it was Elizabeth’s turn.
With me so far?
This all (sort of) makes sense if you accept Elizabeth’s place in the one of succession.
And as a Protestant English man or woman it did.
But Elizabeth had been considered illegitimate.
Moreover, Henry VIII’s first marriage to Catherine of Aragon, had never been annulled by the Pope.
It was this refusal by the Pope that Henry used as a pretext to break away from Rome.
To those English subjects who remained Catholic this was a major problem.
Basically, without Papal authority otherwise, that first marriage was legally binding and all the other 5 marriages were invalid.
Thus to many Catholics in England and elsewhere in Europe, the only true heir to Henry was the daughter from that first marriage - Mary.
She was now dead so who was next in line?
Elizabeth, as they saw it, was not eligible - whatever the old king had dictated in his Act of Succession.
Who was the next Catholic in the family tree.
Both by following the line of the eldest of Henry’s siblings & discounting the offspring of his younger sister who were Protestants, who come down the line from Margaret into the Royal House of Scotland, the Stuarts, and to Mary Queen of Scots.
We can get into lots of debate, and now is not the time, but many Catholics in Europe and in England saw Mary not just in the line of succession but the true Queen of England - right here, right now.
In fact, her father-in-law had added the Lions of England to her French coat of arms which already contained the lion of Scotland and the French flour de lys.
For Mary this wasn’t some pub or university debate. This was real and she saw her claim as absolutely valid.
Over in England, Queen Elizabeth was all to aware of the danger than this rival posed.
And it was this political rivalry, far more than who was more beautiful or some of Mary’s passions that was to set the tone for their relationship and Mary’s ultimate tragedy.
Mary reign as Queen Consort of France ended almost before it began. Francis died after just 16 months on the throne.
Mary was now just shy of her 20th birthday and a widow.
There was no role for a young Dowager Queen in France and so in August 1461, Mary set sail for her native Scotland.
She had been absent for 13 years.
One of the classic mistakes in films about Mary Queen of Scots is that the heroines speak in a beautiful Scottish accent.
The reality is that seeing as she had spent the last 13 years in France, she would have spoken with a French accent, but why spoil a good story!
Lack of Scottish accent apart, Mary was, by all accounts, beautiful.
Tall (5” 11), slender, with auburn hair and hazel eyes.
The young Queen of Scots took over the reigns of government from the Regency and vowed to reign as a Catholic but respecting the Protestant will of her people.
Preachers like John Knox were not so sure that such a circle could be squared.
He preached against her Catholicism and argued that having a female monarch went against God’s order in the world.
In July 1565, Mary married for a second time.
This time to her half-cousin, Henry Lord Darnley.
At 6 foot, this “Long Lad” as Queen Elizabeth called him - was a perfect physical match for the Queen.
Unfortunately he was no temporal match.
She soon realised that she had married a drunk, who wanted to be crowned king and was highly jealous of his wife’s position.
His jealousy reached its climax when in front of the pregnant queen, he stabbed her advisor David Rizzio to death claiming that he was having an affair with the Queen.
Despite that shock, Mary’s pregnancy went full term and in 1566 she gave birth to a son - named James.
The marriage, however, was over.
Darnley was forced to moved out of the road palace to a house in Kirk O Field, just inside the walls of the city of Edinburgh.
On the 10th February 1557, a huge explosion ripped through the house.
Darnley was found dead in the garden with signs that had had been smothered.
All fingers pointed at the Queen and also her supporter, James Hepburn, the Earl of Bothwell.
Two months later, Bothwell was put on trial but after a 7 hour hearing he was acquitted.
Within a matter of weeks, Bothwell and Mary married.
The nation was shocked.
Europe was shocked.
Down in England, Elizabeth was shocked.
And John Know? He was livid.
The Protestant preacher railed against this Jezebal of a queen, who had married the man implicated in her husband’s murder just 3 months before.
The mood in Scotland turned against Mary.
A force of nobles imprisoned her at Loch Leven Castle in Perthshire.
There the Queen miscarried twins.
In July 1567, Mary was forced to abdicate in favour of her baby son, James.
He was the third successive Scottish monarch to be proclaimed before they were 2 years old.
Once more a Regency Council - domino aged by Protestants - would rule Scotland.
Mary tried to raise an army against the nobles but was defeated.
With no other options left, she fled by boat across the Solway Firth to England, landing at Workington in Cumbria.
She would never see Scotland again.
For the next 19 years she was kept effectively under house arrest in England.
Her new hostess, Queen Elizabeth was presented with a major headache.
On one hand, here was a fellow monarch and relative in need.
On the other hand, here was someone who had openly claimed Elizabeth’s own throne and was seen as a rallying point for many English Catholics.
For the next 19 years, Elizabeth played a balancing act.
She kept Mary far enough away from the Scottish border so that she could not led an invasion to reclaim her throne, which could also lead to a counter-invasion of England from any Scots.
Yet she didn’t want her principle Royal and Catholic opponent anywhere near the capital, London.
So Mary was placed (effectively under house arrest) at Bolton Castle in Yorkshire.
All the while, Elizabeth was faced with regular Catholic conspiracies, in which Mary’s name was regularly mentioned.
Within a couple of years of Mary arriving, two prominent Catholic nobles, Charles Neville (Earl of Westmoreland) and Thomas Percy (Earl of Northumberland) had risen in revolt against Elizabeth in the north of England.
This area, far from London, had retained strong Catholic sympathies.
Indeed, Henry VIII, had faced the Pilgrimage of Grace, from this very area during the Reformation.
Now Percy’s army advanced south capturing Durham and celebrating catholic mass in the cathedral.
Before they could capture York, a government army was assembled and in the face of their superior numbers and firepower, the rebels rapidly dispersed.
Percy was captured and beheaded in York.
The furious Queen ordered that 700 folk be executed.
There was no obvious involvement form Mary but her presence in the north was dangerous and there now followed a series of moves to castles and homes further south in the midlands, including Tutbury Castle and Chatsworth in Derbyshire.
A year later, the Pope excommunicated Elizabeth (not really a problem seeing as she was a Protestant), and issued a Papal Bull - Regnant in Excelsis - which deemed her a heretic, called Elizabeth the “Pretended Queen of England” and released her Catholic subjects from their oath of allegiance to her.
Unfortunately, for Thomas Percy this Papal Bull arrived too late to be used in his rebellion but equally unfortunately, it was seized upon by the Queen’s Protestant supporters and provided a pretext for repression of Catholics, who were now construed as enemies within, taking their orders from a foreign head of government.
A third unfortunate….it inspired another group of Catholics to plot against Elizabeth.
Two years after the Rising of the North, the Ridolfi Plot was uncovered.
Masterminded, if that is the right word, by an Italian financial, the plot aimed to transport 10,000 Spanish troops from the Netherlands to England, murder Elizabeth, release Mary Queen of Scots, place her on the throne and then to marry Mary to the Queen’s cousin (a leading Catholic noble) Thomas Howard, Duke of Norfolk.
The plot was half baked - Ridolfi planned to land the Spanish army in ~Norfolk but wasn’t exactly sure where Norfolk actually was.
Nevertheless, the ring leaders were rounded up and Norfolk was beheaded.
Once more, Mary claimed claimed ignorance of the plot.
12 years were to pass, before the next serious catholic conspiracy - the Throckmorton Plot.
In 1583, a catholic member of the gentry - Sir Francis Throckmorton - whose cousin was a lady in waiting to the queen, hatched a plan to free Mary from her house arrest.
Once more this plot would involve a Spanish invasion.
This time, Elizabeth’s spy master, Francis Walsingham, brought together enough evidence to suggest that rather than being some catholic gentleman’s pipe dream, the Spanish authorities were somehow involved and the Spanish Ambassador was expelled from England.
Sir Francis Throckmorton was executed in 1584.
His cousin, the lady in waiting (Bess Throckmorton) was exonerated and would later marry Sir Walter Raleigh.
As a side-note, two of the key Gunpowder plot conspirators - Robert Catesby and Francis Tresham - were relatives of Sir Francis and the Throckmorton property of Caughton Court in Warwickshire was linked to that Catholic plot in 1605.
In the same year that Throckmorton was executed, yet another Catholic had a go at regime change.
William Parry was convicted of trying to assassinate Queen Elizabeth.
With these regular conspiracies, many linked to the Catholic superpower, Spain, and endorsed by a Papal Bull, it is not hard to see why Elizabeth and her government started to feel under attack k from her Catholic subjects.
Maybe it was a bit like the McCarthy anti-communist campaign in 1950’s America.
If you look hard enough you will see conspiracies everywhere.
And there was no greater anti-catholic “witch-hunter” than Elizabeth’s spy master - Sir Thomas Walsingham.
He was convinced that both Mary was far more involved in these conspiracies than she admitted to, and that whilst she was alive she was a rallying point for Catholics in England.
He determined to, as the phrase goes :” Give her enough rope to hang herself”.
In 1556, another catholic gentleman, Anthony Babbington formulated yet another plan to get rid of as he saw her, the heretic queen Elizabeth and restore England to catholicism.
The plan - assassinate Elizabeth and replace her with Mary Queen of Scots.
Now quite how early, Walsingham found out about the plot is hard to say.
But he did find out and he relaxed security around the Queen of the Scots to messages to pass from the conspirators to Mary.
Messages, that whilst in cipher code , were being read by Walsingham.
So far, so good.
He knew Mary was aware of the Babbington Plot.
But being aware of it wasn’t what the wily spy master wanted. He wanted Mary’s prints, as it were on the metaphorical smoking gun.
On the 6th July, Babbington wrote to Mary explaining the plan.
Using the cipher, Mary replied encouragingly on the 17th July.
It was the evidence that Walsingham had been waiting for.
In her own hand, Mary was encouraging catholics to overthrow her hostess - Elizabeth - and accepted their invitation to replace her.
Fotheringhay castle in Northamptonshire, had been a palace for Catherine of Aragon.
It had actually tended to be the palace of all of Henry VIII’s wives, but for the last 30 years it had been allowed to become dilapidated.
It was to this shabby castle that Mary Queen of Scots was brought for her trial on the 14th October 1586.
The charge was Treason.
Which was an interesting choice of charge, seeing as Mary was technically the subject of the Queen.
Elizabeth’s advisors argued that she had been under the Queen’s protection for the past 19 years which sort of made her a subject.
Furthermore, she was actively conspiring to have Elizabeth overthrown and murdered.
There could be no other charge.
Mary faced a court of 36 noble MEN.
Not a single woman was present.
Walsingham and Queen Elizabeth’s chief minister, Robert Cecil, wanted this over fast.
Mary was allowed no legal representation, she wasn’t allowed to review any of the evidence against her and wasn’t able to call any witnesses.
The verdict was never in doubt, 35 nobles found her guilty of treason, only Lord Zouch dissented.
Elizabeth now dithered for over three months.
Not only was Mary kith & kin, she was a monarch.
If Elizabeth endorsed a trial and then execution of a monarch what precedent would it set - not least for her if any future catholic conspiracy or invasion did prove successful.
Christmas passed, New Year passed.
Eventually on the 1st February she signed the order for execution…and even then she wasn’t sure.
Maybe she wasn’t sure but her counsellors and ministers were.
Before the Queen of England could change her mind the order was raced up to Fotheringhay as fast as a horse could gallop.
At 8am on the 8th February 1587, Mary Queen of Scots entered the Great Hall at Fotheringhay Castle.
Dressed in black, she stepped up onto the hastily assembled scaffold.
Casting off her long black dress she stood resplendent in a crimson dress and brown and crimson sleeves; the signs of Catholic martyrdom.
The beheading of the Queen of Scots was a calamity.
The executioner missed her neck on his first attempt driving his axe into the top of her back, his next swing did hit the mark but failed to sever the head. Whilst Mary was now dead, the executioner was reduced to using a saw to cut off her head.
At the end of this grisly exercise he held her head by the hair and raised it aloft to utter the words “ Here dies a Traitor”.
Unfortunately, Mary had been wearing a wig and her head fell to the ground leaving the executioner waving the wig.
The once beautiful Queen of the Scots had died with short grey hair under her wig, in a macabre execution in a draft hall in a dilated castle.
All the promise and opportunity of those early years had come to this.
The young queen of Scotland and France, married to a drunken abuser, deposed from her throne, a mother who hadn’t seen her only child since he was one, under house arrest for 19 years, and finally after a trial in a kangaroo court, she died in a bother execution.
And so ends one of the saddest stories in British royal history.
Mary Queen of Scots was buried in nearby Peterborough Cathedral.
The Catholic World was aghast.
Pope Sixtus V renewed the Papal Bull against Elizabeth now including regicide in her list of crimes.
It was the duty, he said, of good Catholics to overthrow Elizabeth.
Well, that would have to be someone other than Anthony Babbington. The 24-year old and 13 of his co-conspirators were also found guilty of treason and hanged, drawn and quartered.
The catholic gentry of England were running out of steam but across the ocean a Catholic prince was finally stirring.
Phillip II of Spain, Elizabeth’s former brother-in-law, decided that it was time to act.
If the English catholics couldn’t get rid of Elizabeth, he would by force of arms.
He began to gather an army of invasion and a fleet to transport them…Elizabeth and England were about to meet his mighty Armada.