The History Chap Podcast
The History Chap Podcast
18: Henry VIII & the Break With Rome
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Henry VIII, no talk about English (or Welsh history) would be complete without him!
Famous for marrying 6 wives, executing 2 of them and divorcing another too.
Father of Elizabeth I.
To many English & indeed foreigners, if you ask them to name a king or queen of England - Henry Viii springs to mind.
This larger than life character, who reigned for 37 years is almost a badge of England.
Join my Supporter's Club
And that may be it…because Henry Viii defines Englishness - a sense of independence and national identity.
And it has nothing to do with having 6 wives, and being a bloody tyrant, and a lot more to do with his break with the Roman Catholic Church and establishment of the Church of England.
18. Henry Viii and the break with Rome
Henry Viii, no talk about English (or Welsh history) would be complete without him!
Famous for marrying 6 wives, executing 2 of them and divorcing another too.
Father of Elizabeth I.
But apart from being a a womaniser with an appetite for executions and extravagance, why is he such an iconic English monarch?
Let’s face it George IV (The Prince Regent) was also extravagant, a womaniser and fat and yet he is not in the same league.
To many English & indeed foreigners, if you ask them to name a king or queen of England - Henry Viii springs to mind.
This larger than life character is almost a badge of England.
And that may be it…because Henry Viii defines Englishness - a sense of independence and national identity.
And it has nothing to do with having 6 wives and a lot more to do with his break with the Roman Catholic Church and establishment of the Church of England.
Henry Viii came to the throne when he was just 17 when his father, Henry VII died in 1509.
He was to rule England for the next 37 years.
Henry, was never intended for the throne. He had an older brother, Arthur who’d died 7 years before hand.
Before his death Arthur had married a Spanish princess, Catherine of Aragon.
Now poor Catherine, aged just 17, was a widow in a foreign country.
Old Henry VII has keen to keep England aligned with the new up and coming super-power that was Spain, and saw a marriage between his new heir (Henry) and the widowed Catherine as a pragmatic way forward.
The Pope however noted that marrying your brother’s wife was strictly forbidden in the Old Testament and refused to sanction the arrangement.
So, Catherine stayed marooned in London for the next 7 years, during which time she served as the Spanish Ambassador to England (the first woman to ever be an ambassador in European history).
Swearing that her marriage to Arthur had never been consummated, the Pope finally gave dispensation for her marriage to be annulled and two months after he had assumed the throne young Henry finally married the Spanish princess.
They were crowned at Westminster Abbey on midsummers day 1509.
In all the fun & games of Henry Viii and his 6 wives, it is easy to forget that Catherine was by far his longest marriage. Their 24 year union was three times all his other marriages put together.
The Tudors had come to power out of the chaos of the Wars of the Roses.
That dynastic civil war had torn the house of Plantagenet apart and ultimately brought about its demise.
Henry Viii (rather like his father) was committed (maybe even paranoid) to prevent a similar fate happening to his dynasty. What he needed was a Male heir to continue the line.
And therein lay the undoing of his marriage to Catherine of Aragon.
It had all started so well.
Less than two years after that glorious summer coronation, Queen Catherine had given birth to a boy. Guns fired salutes across London to honour Henry, Duke of Cornwall. But the celebrations were short lived - the baby prince died after just 6 weeks.
Catherine was to miscarry or give birth to two more still-born sons and a daughter in the coming years.
Finally in 1516 Catherine successfully gave birth to a child who lived.. The only problem was that the baby was a girl…Princess Mary.
Catherine was now in her 30’s and Henry was getting fretful.
It is unclear how many mistresses Henry had. In fairness, it was almost an expectation that kings had mistresses at this time (and for quite a period beyond).
What we do know, is that Elizabeth Blount bore him a son in 1519.
Rumours persist that Henry had other illegitimate children but this son, Henry Fitzroy, was the only one acknowledged by the King.
Indeed, he was not merely acknowledged. Henry showered him with favours and honours.
He was created the Duke of Somerset and Duke of Richmond, becoming the most senior noble in the kingdom.
As the 1520’s progressed, Catherine was now in her 40’s. Realistically, the chances of her giving birth to an heir (or certainly one that lived and also happened to be a boy) were getting longer and longer…if not nigh impossible.
The king started to weigh up his options. How was he going to continue his dynasty?
He did have a legitimate heir, the Princess Mary.
One option was to marry her off to a suitable husband, maybe a European prince.
But, Mary was only 10 and it could be at least a decade before she had produce ed a healthy (male) heir. Moreover, to successfully assume power, that unborn heir would need to ideally be in his majority.
So we are talking 25 years hence - Henry would need to reach his 60’s to ensure a smooth (unchallenged) succession.
And anyway, due to her marriage, the Princess Mary’s child wouldn’t actually be a Tudor.
Option 2. Legitimise Henry Fitzroy and make him officially heir.
The problem is that he would need to Pope to agree to this about-turn.
And even if that religious and legal hurdle was successfully negotiated, his inheritance could be challenged. Both of his sisters had children who were legitimate heirs of Henry VII, including the Scottish royal family - the Stuarts. There were still far-off members of the Plantagenet family knocking around too.
That left the increasingly desperate king, with a third and final option. Get rid of Catherine and marry someone else.
Not only was Catherine’s age and lack of successful pregnancies a practical issue, Henry started to believe that his marriage and dynastic future were doomed because he had married his bother’s wife.
Yes, the Pope had annulled the marriage between Catherine and Arthur because Catherine swore that the marriage had never been consummated. But, argued Henry, what if she wasn’t telling the truth?
What if that marriage had been consummated?
Then he would be committing a heinous sin…which God was punishing him for by not providing a heir.
All he needed to do was convince the Pope that his predecessor had made a mistake, that the marriage was unlawful and should be annulled immediately.
Then as a free-man (without God’s judgment on him) Henry could marry someone else.
The only problem with this brilliant, theological idea, was that he needed the Pope to be onboard.
Unfortunately for Henry, the current Pope was subservient to the Hapsburg emperor That emperor (Charles V) was Catherine of Aragon’s nephew.
There was no way that the Emperor was going to allow the Pope to sanction that indignity on his aunt.
Henry was between a rock and a hard place.
His senior minister, Cardinal Wolsey, who had failed to get the Pope to bend to Henry’s will was ousted (and executed).
Famously, Henry took over Wolsey’s palace at Hampton Court.
And now events took a very English turn….events that were to change England forever.
At this point in the history of Europe there was a growing challenge to the Roman Catholic Church, which was the form of christianity practised across the whole of western and northern Europe.
Martin Luther had challenged the fundamental principles of Catholicism - in particular the notions that sin could be redeemed by good works, that the Mass was anything more than symbolic and, most importantly that liturgy was more important than the word of God, as written in The Bible.
Many people saw the Catholic focus on worshipping at shrines and the importance of holy relics as either nothing to do with The Bible or pure money-making exercises by the church.
This Protestant reformation was gathering pace in Germany and Scandinavia. It had its supporters in England too, but they had, historically, been in the minority.
The bulk of the King’s realm, including the King himself, were loyal catholics.
Indeed, in 1521 Henry had refuted the arguments made by Martin Luther in an essay which resulted in the grateful Pope (Leo X) giving him the title “Defender of the faith” - a title which monarchs of England posses to this day.
But now, Henry rather like his Protestant subjects was fast approaching a fall-out with the Pope.
Henry wanted to annul his marriage, re-marry and produce an heir.
Yet, despite being King of England, he was being thwarted by the Pope in Rome.
Worse still, the English clergy in their churches and, in particular, the 800 monastic houses in the country, took their orders from Rome.
They paid taxes to the Pope.
They obeyed the Popes rulings
They had their own courts.
They were quite literally a law unto themselves.
Henry saw them almost like a fifth column…a community in his own kingdom who took their lead from a leader outside of England and could thwart the king’s ambitions.
So we had a political impasse with the Pope over his marriage to Catherine, a growing Protestant reformation and a desire to have total control over his own kingdom.
And then there was money.
The monasteries, in particular, were rich. They were so financially self-sufficient that despite paying at least 5% of their income to the Pope and they were still well off.
Henry, on the other hand, liked to “splash the cash.”
His love of palaces refurbishments and decoration (Henry bought 2,000 tapestries when in the same period the King of Scotland bought just 200), feasting, clothing and jewellery had made a huge dent in the treasury that he had inherited from his avaricious father.
What was left in the diminishing treasury was fast used up on pointless military expeditions in France and a desire to invest in all things military, especially the Royal Navy.
How could he pay fund being a king?
Well, what if those taxes that were sent to the Pope were, instead, sent to him?
Indeed, what if those rich self-sufficient monasteries were his personal cash cow?
Better still, how about selling them to England’s powerful nobles and up & coming merchants and pocketing the proceeds?
Thus for a whole variety of competing reasons Henry was set for a showdown with the Pope in Rome.
The priority, in Henry’s mind, was to secure the Tudor Dynasty by getting rid of Catherine and marrying someone else…that someone else being Anne Boleyn.
Enter Thomas Cromwell.
This lawyer became his advocate, conducted and enforcer in parliament; a parliament that was increasingly sympathetic to reform or indeed Protestantism.
In 1533 Parliament passed the Act in Restraint of Appeals.
By law, senior leaders of the church could no longer appeal on religious matters to the Pope.
They were, instead subject to the King’s judgments.
Immediately, with that right of appeal to the Pope out of the way, the Protestant leaning Archbishop of Canterbury, Thomas Cramner, convened a special court at Dunstable Priory to consider the royal marriage.
Strangely enough Cramner declared the marriage null and void and Queen Catherine was reduced to the rank of Princess Dowager.
Poor Catherine.
A wife who stuck by him for 24 years. Who had calm accepted his parading of his illegitimate son around the court, who had held the country for him whilst he was on campaign in France and whose army (under the Earl of Surrey) had destroyed a Scottish invasion at the battle of Flodden Field, was tossed aside.
She was to die less than three years later at Kimbolton castle and is buried at Peterborough Cathedral. Interestingly, he tomb bears the words “Katherine, Queen of England”. It seems I am not the only one who thinks she was hard done by.
In the meantime, Henry had married Anne Boleyn and within 3 months she had born him an heir…but once again it was not the boy Henry so desperately desired. It was a girl: Princess Elizabeth.
Despite this set back he lost no time in getting Parliament to pass the Act of Succession - declaring the daughter of his marriage with Catherine (the teenage Mary) illegitimate and barred from the line of succession. Instead his heir would be Princess Elizabeth (well, until the longed-for boy arrived anyway).
The following year, 1534, Cromwell oversaw the Act of Supremacy, which replaced the Pope as head of the church in England with the king. From now it would be the Church OF England with the monarch at its head…and that too remains to this day.
On the back of that Act another law was passed - the Act for the submission of the clergy - requiring all clergy to swear an oath of loyalty to the king as head of the church.
Clergy were left with only two options. Aquiesse or break the law.
The final, part of this triple attack in 1534 was the Treason Act. Whereby anyone refusing to acknowledge Henry as head of the church of England was guilty of treason. The punishment of which was death. And many clergy were to pay that ultimate price.
Henry had two of the three things he desired…a new wife and total independence from Rome.
That just left the task of replenishing his treasury.
But before he could get cracking on that Anne Boleyn had fallen from grace and was executed in 1536. A day later, he became engaged to wife number 3 - Jane Seymour and within 6 months she delivered the male heir that he had always wanted - the future Edward VI. Jane was to die 12 days after the birth.
Even before Edward’s birth, Henry had passed a second Act of Succession barring Elizabeth as well as Mary from the crown. It also gave the king the right to determine his line of succession in his will.
At this moment, with 2 children barred and the third yet to be born, Henry could have died and nominated Henry Fitzroy as his heir (despite the whole illegitimate thing. But then as he was now head of the church of England he didn’t need Papal approval, he could do what he chose).
The moment didn’t last long. Just a month later, the young Duke of Richmond & Somerset had died, probably of Tuberculosis.
But just for a tantalising month, we might have ended up with a King Henry IX.
Anyway, back to the cash cows that were England’s monasteries.
Cromwell was a man on a mission and through persuasion and harassment pressure was put on the monasteries to close their doors.
Some monastic communities actually forced their abbots to agree so that they could each receive the promised pension of £5 pa (which, as the equivalent income of a skilled worker was a tempting bribe).
The dissolution of the monasteries were conducted over a 7 year period and it was total.
By 1542 over 800 had been closed and left to the elements or to local folk to plunder for bricks and tiles.
Some monasteries became colleges.
Yet another Act of Parliament decreed that parts of Abbey’s used for congregational worship were to be retained, walled off from the derelict monastery next door. 117 such Abbey churches were created and most remain to this day.
As planned, the Crown benefited form an enormous financial windfall of approximately £150,000 pa (or £100m pa in today’s money).
Cromwell had intended to use these funds to fun d the government of the realm - almost not needing any further taxes.
The King, however, had other plans.
He was planning a war with both France and Scotland and needed cash fast. So he sold off most of the monastic properties to the highest bidders.
Henry Viii has often been called the “Father of the English navy”. During his reign he built the Royal Navy from a measly 15 ships that he inherited from his father to nearly 50 by the time of his death.
He took a keen interest in the design of new vessels and encouraged the use of gunport and heavy bronze cannon thus moving the navy from the medieval tactics of ramming and boarding to cannon bombardment.
Alongside his programme of ship building, the King established the first dry-dock at Portsmouth and also the construction of forts stretching the entire length of the south coast to protect his harbours.
For all his expenditure, Henry’s results against the French during their war in the early 1540’s were far from spectacular.
In 1544 he had personally taken command of an invasion of northern France where his sole success was the capture of the port of Boulogne.
The following year, the French attempted to repay their old rival by invading England.
On land they were defeated when they tried to occupy the isle of Wight whilst at sea they were defeated off Portsmouth in the Battle of the Solent.
It was in this battle, that Henry’s flagship, the Mary Rose capsized with almost all hands drowned.
In the ensuing peace treaty, Henry was allowed to keep Boulogne for 8 years after which they would pay England 2 million marks to retake control. Henry agreed to the deal…despite all that monastic windfall he was once more broke!
Despite the break with Rome and the dissolution of the monasteries, Henry was not a Protestant.
His policy was once of opportunism.
Cromwell on the other hand saw the Reformation through a distinct Protestant lens.
He enforced a rule that all churches should have a bible and within a year he had placed an English bible - rather than Latin (called the “Great Bible”) in 9,000 churches across the country.
No more would priests be able to hide behind Latin liturgy, the people could have access to Go’s Word in their native tongue.
It was Cromwell who led the attack on religious shrines despite many in the court being catholic in their outlook.
By 1538 he was politically strong enough to order the destruction of the shrine of St. Thomas Beckett in Canterbury Cathedral.
In the next two years, his officials looted and demolished sites of pilgrimage across England including at Glastonbury, Walsingham, Bury St. Edmunds and even Alfred The Great’s tomb at Winchester.
By the time the destruction had run its course so had Cromwell.
Brought down by his jealous (& often religiously conservative) opponents in court, he was executed on a series of suspicious charges.
For the remainder of Henry’s reign the religious policy of England swung between radical Protestantism (as espoused by henry’s final wife, Katherine Parr) and Catholicism (with the King not the Pope as itsits head).
When the King died in 1547, he died more of a Catholic than a Protestant.
So apart from 6 wives and a 54 inch girth what did he achieve.
Two pointless wars with France and Scotland which failed to give England any strategic advantage but which almost bankrupted England.
He allowed Cromwell to smash up shrines and tombs going back to before the Norman Conquest and left 800 monasteries in ruin.
He happily sanctioned violence including executions to establish himself as the supreme head of the church in England instead of the Pope. Thousands of clergy and lay people who refused to abandon the Pope were executed. Hundreds of Catholics who revolted in Lincolnshire, Norfolk and Cornwall along with over 200 rebel leaders in the Pilgrimage of Grace in the north of England were put to death.
Political enemies were dispatched as were potential dynastic rivals.
It has been estimated that 50,000 or more were executed for one crime or another during his reign. That from a population of around 2.5 million.
And this barbaric treatment was not reserved just for men. Whether it was Margaret Pole’s bottled beheading or the torturing a so-called heretic, Anne Askew, on the rack in the Tower of London, Henry’s reign showed a level of cruelty that even some of the medieval kings would have winced at.
Hardly reasons to see him as some sort of national emblem.
The distribution of the “Great Bible” to churches across the country not only gave access to the Bible in English, more importantly for the very first time across the whole country people were reading the same English.
The dissolution of the monasteries led to the greatest shift in land ownership since the Norman invasion in 1066 and it has never been repeated.
In less than a decade 16% of all the land in England changed hands.
Yet, it was the break with Rome that was to be Henry VIII’s lasting legacy.
By declaring himself Head of the Church of England and through his Act in restraint of Appeals, he cut the Church of England adrift from the Roman Catholic Church.
Unlike, England’s European neighbours and rivals, England was answerable to no one outside of the country.
This led to a profound increase in England’s sense of autonomy and self identity.
Separated from the continent by the sea, England was apart from Europe.
The English increasingly saw themselves as masters & mistresses of their own identity which was to outlive the short tenure of the Tudors and still resonates to this very day.
That, whilst not as sexy as the 6 wives, is Henry VIII’s true legacy.