The History Chap Podcast
The History Chap Podcast
17: Dawn Of The Tudors
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
The Tudors are probably the most famous, the most talked about royal dynasty in England or, indeed, in Britain’s history.
Yet they did not arrive on the throne through the natural line of succession.
Their arrival was entirely due to victory on the battlefield during the medieval civil war known as the Wars of the Roses.In 1485, Henry Tudor defeated King Richard III at the Battle of Bosworth Field.
And yet how legitimate was his claim to the throne?
And
How secure was his grip on power?
In this episode I uncover the answer to both of those questions...
The Tudors are probably the most famous, the most talked about royal dynasty in England or, indeed, in Britain’s history.
Yet they did not arrive on the throne through the natural line of succession.
Their arrival was entirely due to victory on the battlefield during the medieval civil war known as the Wars of the Roses.
It’s not that the Tudors didn’t have a claim to the throne, it’s just that they didn’t have the best claim.
In 1485, Henry Tudor defeated King Richard III at the Battle of Bosworth Field.
Ostentatiously, Henry, represented the hopes of the House of Lancaster during this dynastic civil war against the House of York.
Those two houses represented warring factions within the Royal house of Plantagenet.
Yet, as Henry’s surname (& new dynasty) made very plain, he was not a Plantagenet.
Victorious on the battlefield Henry may have been but secure he was not.
For a start, how legitimate was his claim?
Henry’s claim to the throne of England was through his mother Margaret Beaufort.
She was a descendent of the illegitimate line of John of Gaunt, Duke of Lancaster, the third son of King Edward III.
The House of Lancaster were the descendants of John of Gaunt’s legitimate line.
The House of York - including the now dead Richard III, were also legitimate descendants of Edward III.
It was just that the brutal Wars of the Roses had eliminated all those legitimate Lancastrian descendants. So by de-fault, the only male relative of John of Gaunt left standing was Henry Tudor.
Whilst he had the royal blood of Edward III in his veins, that was only due to John of Gaunts extra-marital activities, so how solid was his claim seeing as he was the illegitimate great-great-great grandson of Edward III.
Compare that to the House of York.
Richard of York had a straight (legitimate) line back to Edward III through both his mother and his father. Thus, so too did his children - Edward IV, Richard III, George Duke of Clarence, Margaret Duchess of Burgundy and Elizabeth de La Pole. And thus their children.
Putting it very frankly, Henry Tudor’s claim to the throne was weak.
The practical reality is that Henry’s claim to the throne had a lot more to do with killing Richard III at Bosworth than having a river of blue blood flowing through his veins.
But that WAS the reality.
And moving quickly he was crowned king Henry VII at Westminster Abbey on the 30th October.
Next he moved to secure his legitimacy and that of his future dynasty by marrying strengthening his royal credentials.
In January 1486 - 3 months after his coronation, 5 months after his victory at Bosworth, Henry married the daughter of Edward IV - Elizabeth of York.
Their children would have the blood of both the House of Lancaster and the House of York in their veins.
Symbolically he created a new emblem to show this unity. The Tudor rose combined the red rose of Lancaster and the white rose of York.
Whilst marrying marrying Edward IV’s daughter would add legitimacy to his children and his dynasty it didn’t mean that the Yorkist threat was removed.
Just because Richard III was dead that didn’t mean that the Yorkist cause was lost.
Richard left 2 sisters alive, along with 5 nieces & 5 nephews.
Henry VII was far from secure.
All the Yorkists needed was another leader to rally around.
But who?
The most obvious candidate was the son of Richard III and Edward IV’s bother - George Duke of Clarence - the 10 year old Edward Earl of Warwick.
The problems, apart from his age was that his father had died a traitor and therefore he was ruled out of the running.
Nevertheless, Henry took no chances and immediately after his victory at Bosworth he had the young Earl of Warwick arrested & taken to the Tower of London for safe keeping.
There was however, a far more dangerous threat - the four sons of Richard & Edwards’ sister - the de la Poles.
At 25 years of age, the eldest brother John de la Pole, Earl of Lincoln just 3 years younger than Henry himself - more than capable of leading an armed revolt.
Moreover, there was no ambiguity over his rights to succession - unlike his cousin the Earl of Warwick.
In fact his claim was so strong that when Richard III’s son had died, Richard had made John heir presumptive.
All right, so his claim came through his mother (Elizabeth de la Pole) but as Henry based his claim through his mother (Margaret Beaufort) he couldn’t really use that one against the Earl of Lincoln.
Alongside John de la Pole were his three brothers Edmund, William and Richard.
Enough to make Henry pause for thought.
And then there was another intriguing possibility.
Edward IV had two sons (Elizabeth of York’s brothers) two young teenagers, Edward & Richard.
The eldest, had succeeded his father as Edward V.
However, Uncle Richard had usurped the throne, claiming that Edward IV and Elizabeth Woodville’s marriage was invalid and that both Edward V and his brother were therefore out of the line of succession.
The brothers were placed in the Tower of London and never seen again.
Most people believed that they had been killed and most fingers pointed at Richard III.
But, what if Edward V or his brother had not been murdered?
OK, there might be a question over their legitimacy but then, once again, Henry Tudor’s line came from the illegitimate grandchildren of Edward III.
And their father was most definitely a legitimate king.
What if they were still alive, waiting to return?
Enter Lambert Simnel.
In May 1487, 18 months after Henry’s coronation a rival was proclaimed king.
Lambert Simnel was born of humble origins but priest , Richard Simon had tutored him with enough reading, learning and etiquette to pass him off as a noble.
After initially claiming that he was Richard of York (the younger prince in the tower), Simon changed his story and claimed that Lambert Simnel was in fact Edward Earl of Warwick, who had escaped from the Tower.
Simon took Lambert to Ireland where there was still strong Yorkist support and there on the 24th May 1487, in Christchurch cathedral in Dublin, Lambert was crowned King Edward VI.
And then he was joined by none other than John de la Pole, Earl of Lincoln, supported by 2,000 Swiss mercenaries supplied by Richard & Edwards other sister - Margaret Duchess of Burgundy.
Did the Earl of Lincoln really believe that this was his cousin, Warwick, or did he see him as a useful pawn in his own ambitions for the throne?
Similarly, did the Duchess of Burgundy see Simnel as her nephew (she publicly claimed he was) or was she just looking for any reason to level the score with Henry Tudor?
We don’t know.
What we do know is that on the 4th June, Simnel, the Earl of Lincoln, their Swiss mercenaries and a force of Irish landed in Lancashire.
Covering an impressive 200 miles in 5 days, they crossed the Pennines and moved south pushing a Royalist army that had come to check them back through Sherwood Forest to Nottingham.
By now the main royalist army led Henry himself was approaching Nottingham from London.
On the 15th June 1487, Henry moved his army eastwards along the old Fosse Road from Nottingham towards Newark, following the south bank of the River Trent.
And just outside the village of East Stoke they found the rebel army, which had crossed the Trent, formed up ready for them.
The Royalist army of 12,000 outnumbered Simbert & Lincoln’s rebel, who stood at 8,000.
As Royalist arrows rained down the rebels charged off the high ground.
A wild charge of Irish fury and disciplined, battle-hardened Swiss mercenaries.
The Royalist line buckled but Henry’s veteran commander, the Earl of Oxford held his men and his archers started to slaughter the lightly armoured Irish. The Swiss mercenaries were armed with hand guns but could not match the archers rate of fire.
And then Oxford ordered his own charge.
The rebels were trapped between the advancing Royal army and the River Trent.
It was a bloodbath.
Over 4,000 rebels died and anything between 500-3,000 Royalists. John de la Pole, Earl of Lincoln was killed in the fighting.
Lambert Simnel was captured.
Whilst some say that Bosworth was the end of the Wars of The Roses it is fair to say that the Battle of Stoke Fields was. There was never another battle of this size in England until the English Civil War, 160 years later.
Henry had survived.
He realised that Simnel was just a puppet and put him to work in the royal kitchens.
But it was not over yet.
Then in 1490 another pretender to the throne appeared - Perkin Warbeck.
Once again, backed by Margaret of Burgundy claimed to be Richard, the younger of the two Princes in the Tower.
He attempted a landing at Deal in Kent but his force was defeated before he could even land.
Further attempts to raise a rebellion in the north and in Ireland failed completely.
In September 1497, he landed in Cornwall with just 120 men and gathered an army of 6,000 Cornishmen who declared him Richard IV. Capturing the city of Exeter his army then advanced into Somerset.
However, upon hearing that government troops were gathering he deserted his own men and was captured at Beaulieu Abbey in Hampshire.
Paraded through the streets of London to much derision, Warbeck was imprisoned in the Tower.
In 1499 he and Edward Earl of Warwick attempted to escape.
Henry had them executed - two pretenders out of the way in a brutal swift and brutal manner. You crossed the Tudors at your peril.
And still the Yorkist threats would not go away.
Enter, Edmund de la Pole, the Earl of Suffolk, and younger brother of John, Earl of Lincoln.
Unlike Warbeck or Simnel he was definitely a legitimate claimant - arguably with as strong a claim to the throne than Henry himself.
After Bosworth he had sworn allegiance to Henry but…well Henry was wary and tried to keep Edmund at court.
In 1501 he fled England with his youngest brother Richard.
He made his way to Austria, where the Emperor, Maximilian I acknowledged him as the Yorkist pretender but refused to fund any rebellion. Edmund continued to tour Europe seeking support.
In 1506 he was en-route to Spain when his ship was blown off course…ending up in England.
Henry could not believe his good luck!
Edmund was placed under lock & key at the Tower of London.
He was not pardoned upon Henry VIII’s ascension to the throne. He remained in the Tower of London where, 4 years later he was beheaded. Henry VIII was not leaving anything to chance.
The very last active Yorkist claimant was Edmunds youngest brother, Richard de la Pole.
In 1514, a year after brother Edmund had been executed, Richard gathered a force of 12,000 in the port of St. Malo in France ready to invade England.
And then, France signed a peace treaty with England and the King of France quietly wound down Richard’s venture. He remained in France and died in 1525 fighting for the French against the Hapsburg'sHapsburg's in Italy.
And what of the fourth brother?
William was the only one of the de la Pole brothers never to actually press a claim for the throne.
Nevertheless, because of his credentials and also his other 3 brothers willingness to challenge the Tudors, he was locked in the Tower in 1501 - the year Edmund absconded to the continent.
He was to remain a guest in the Tower of London until his death in 1539.
Never an active Yorkist claimant and never executed, William de la Pole does hold the record as the longest ever prisoner held in the Tower.
Just as an aside. Some people ask me how Margaret Pole (famously executed in a botched beheading on the orders of Henry VIII) fits in with the brothers.
The short answer is that she doesn’t!
She is Margaret Pole not de la Pole - two separate surnames.
However, they were related.
If you remember, the de la Pole brothers claim to the throne was through their mother, Elizabeth - the sister of Edward IV and Richard III.
There was another brother - George, Duke of Clarence. He had been executed (by his brother) as a traitor, leaving his son, Edward Earl of Warwick as a potential leader of the Yorkist cause.
Do you remember I said that Henry imprisoned him in the Tower and then had him executed in 1499?
Well, Edward had an older sister - Margaret Plantagenet, Countess of Salisbury.
She married a Welsh supporter (and cousin) of Henry VII - Richard Pole.
Hence her married name, Margaret Pole.
So she was a cousin to the de la Pole boys and a potential Yorkist claimant in her own right.
Margaret and her sons were to be a thorn in the side of Henry VIII which owing to her position in the line of succession ultimately sealed her death warrant.
Anyway, let’s come back up from that particular rabbit hole.
Despite his shaky claim to the throne, Henry VII was to wear the crown for 24 years until his death.
Compared to his larger-than-life son, Henry VIII or his granddaughter, Elizabeth I, Henry’s reign was unremarkable…almost boring.
After the chaos of the Wars of the Roses, Henry sought to bring stability to England.
His ingenious taxation of the nobles resulted in a constant stream of revenue coming into the previously empty treasury.
By increasing the number and scope of Justices of the Peace, Henry curtailed the local influence of the major nobles.
Probably, Henry’s greatest achievement was actually surviving and founding a dynasty which, despite only ruling England for 3 generations, is still the most talked about in English history.
Henry and Elizabeth of York were married for 17 years and by all accounts had a very happy marriage.
She bore 7 children. Four of whom reached adulthood.
Henry used his off-spring to increase England’s influence on the European stage.
His daughter, Margaret married King James IV of Scotland. It was an attempt to split the Auld Alliance (of Scotland and France against England). In the short term it failed but ultimately, it was Henry’s great-great grandson from this marriage who would wear the crowns of both England and Scotland (James I) and effectively end that all alliance.
Another daughter, Mary was to marry the King of France.
Maybe it was his powers of survival - both in the Wars of the Roses and since his ascension that instinctively made Henry VII aware, before most other European leaders, that the Spanish discoveries in the Americas was going to change the balance of power in Europe.
He lost no time in arranging a marriage between his eldest son and heir and the Spanish crown.
The daughter of the King & Queen of Spain, married the Prince of Wales. Her name was Catherine of Aragon.
You may not have heard of her husband.
Yeah, you’ve heard of Henry VIII. But Catherine initially married Henry’s older brother - Prince Arthur.
That’s right, Henry was not initially heir to the throne, he was the spare!
It was Arthur who was destined to be king of England….Henry was making a nod to his Welsh ancestors.
Arthur & Catherine travelled to Ludlow Castle where Arthur had been promoted by his father to be President of the Council of the Marches - the body that was charged with governing Wales and the English counties that bordered it. Perfect administrative training for a future king.
And there, at Ludlow, in 1502 Prince Arthur died just before his 16th birthday.
He is buried in Worcester Cathedral. The king that England never had.
Within a year his wife, Elizabeth of York had died shortly after giving birth to a baby girl.
The baby girl, Katherine had only survived a few days.
Elizabeth was just 37.
That same year, he escorted his daughter, Margaret, to the Scottish border as she journeyed to her wedding with the king of the Scots.
He was never to see her again.
For the last 6 years of his life, Henry became more morose, more insular, more listless.
He died in 1509, after a reign of 24 years.
He was succeeded by his second son, who was proclaimed King Henry VIII.
It was the first successful handover from a king to an adult son in 100 years.
And now the story of the Tudors really starts to get going!