The History Chap Podcast
The History Chap Podcast
16. Scotland & the Auld Enemy
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
On the 24th June 1314 Robert the Bruce and his outnumbered Flower of Scotland faced Edward II’s English army and send them packing home. In truth the majority of Edward’s army weren’t sent packing from Scotland, they never got off the battlefield alive. The Scots still savour this victory at the battle of Bannockburn.
The victory at Bannockburn not only ensured Scottish independence from England for the next 300 years but instilled a deep sense of pride and consciousness in the Scottish nation which resonates to this very day - as you can hear when Flower of Scotland is belted out at Hamden Park or Murrayfield.
But how did Scotland and England’s stories get to this point?
That is what you are going to find out in this episode.
If you have ever been to, or watched a Scottish team competing in an international sporting tournament, you will probably have heard the rousing unofficial Scottish anthem - “Flower of Scotland”
Written by the folk band, The Corries, it celebrates the most famous victory of the Scots over the English.
On the 24th June 1314 Robert the Bruce and his outnumbered Flower of Scotland faced Edward II’s English army and send them packing home. In truth the majority of Edward’s army weren’t sent packing from Scotland, they never got off the battlefield alive. The Scots still savour this victory at the battle of Bannockburn.
The victory at Bannockburn not only ensured Scottish independence from England for the next 300 years but instilled a deep sense of pride and consciousness in the Scottish nation which resonates to this very day - as you can hear when Flower of Scotland is belted out at Hamden Park or Murrayfield.
But how did Scotland and England’s stories get to this point?
That is what you are going to find out in this episode.
The last time we talked about Scotland was back in talk number 8, when I explained the birth of Scotland as a nation. We ended with Malcolm Canmore defeating MacBeth to become King Malcolm III.
Malcolm himself was king of Scotland in 1066 when William the Conqueror invaded England.
He had close links to the Anglo-Saxon royal family, indeed he was married to Edward the Confessor’s nice, Margaret of Wessex.
Margaret’s brother was Edgar the Aethling, who (if you remember from talk 9) was proclaimed king of England after Harold’s defeat at Hastings. However, Edgar was never crowned and soon afterwards he submitted to William.
I know, I know, you are thinking “I thought this was about Scotland not England”, but you are falling into the trap of viewing this old rivalry as black & white, whereas there is a lot of grey.
As you are going to discover, the royal families and the nobility of Scotland and England were a lot closer intwined than Mel Gibson in “Braveheart” would have you believe.
First off, Malcolm of Scotland and Margaret of Wessex’s daughter, Edith married King Henry I of England (Williams the Conqueror’s son).
So here we are just 34 years after the Battle of Hastings and the English & Scottish royal families have a connection.
Henry & Edith’s daughter, Matilda fought the civil war in England with Stephen (which you can hear in my talk entitled “Anarchy & Lionheart”.
Their grandson, through Matilda, was Henry II (the first of the Plantagenet kings of England) from whom our current Queen, Elizabeth II, is descended. Thus, because of that marriage between Henry I & Edith, The Queen can trace her lineage right back to the ancient house of Wessex (king Alfred the Great and beyond).
Upon Malcolm’s death in 1093 a dynastic civil war erupted in Scotland, between his son from his first marriage (Duncan) and Malcolm’s brother, Donald (the Donaldbaine in Shakespeare’s “MacBeth”).
Despite being crowned king at the traditional coronation venue of Scottish kings, Scone, Duncan was killed in battle fighting Uncle Donald, who now ruled Scotland as Donald III . However, Donald was already in his 60’s and died after just 3 years leaving a daughter.
As we have already seen in my talk on Stephen & Matilda in England, women were definitely only to be considered rulers as a last resort….ie. if there were no suitable men.
And, there were suitable men at this juncture in Scottish history.
There were 3 sons from Malcolm Canmore and his second wife, Margaret of Wessex.
All three were to wear the crown - Edgar, Alexander & finally David.
It was David who, as David I, invaded England in support of his niece, Matilda during her civil war with Stephen.
If you recall from my previous talk, David managed to help himself to a large part of northern England in the process. Lands that were still in his possession when he died in 1153 at the age of 69.
The crown passed to his grandson - Malcolm IV.
Malcolm died childless and the crown passed to his brother, William, known to history as William the Lion. William’s reign of 59 years is only surpassed in Scottish history by James VI (James I of England). Another quiz fact for you!
His son, Alexander II signed the treaty of York with the English in 1327 which effectively established the border between England & Scotland that we recognise today.
So apart from David I’s foray into northern England during The Anarchy, Scotland had been out of England’s orbit for well over a century.
But that was about to change for several reasons.
First off, Alexander’s son (Alexander III - these royals like to make things confusing!) married Margaret, the daughter of Henry III of England. Once more the royal families of Scotland and England are linked.
When Henry III down in England died he was succeeded by Margaret’s brother - Edward I - “Longshanks”
We have come across him in a previous talk too - it was Edward I who snuffed out Welsh independence.
Whilst Edward was enlarging English power in Wales, Alexander was enlarging his own kingdom.
In the 1260’s he delivered a crushing defeat to the Norwegians at the battle of Larges (in the firth of Clyde) and in the ensuing peace treaty wrested the Western Isles (along with the Isle of Man) from Norse control. Now only orkney & Shetland were not part of what we now know as Scotland.
Just three years after Edward’s ascension in England, his sister up in Scotland died.
That in itself was not a problem, Alexander and his brother-in-law were on amicable terms.
But then in 1286 everything was turned on its head.
Alexander died aged just 45.
Unfortunately his two sons had already pre-deceased him, as had his daughter who was married to the King of Norway.
Both sons had died childless but at least his daughter (Margaret) and her husband, (Eric II of Norway) had a child…a daughter… age 3….Margaret, Maid of Norway.
Remember what I said earlier, that women were only candidates for the crown as a last resort?
Well, this was a last resort.
Eric of Norway was wary of letting his 3-year old daughter travel to Scotland as it was far from certain that all those far-off male relatives would submit to her - a girl, aged just 3. This was prime time for ambitious noblemen with a tiny era e of blue-blood in their veins.
And then her great-uncle, Edward I of England stepped in.
He would support her claim to the throne of ScotlandLet us not forget that Edward was not only king of Scotlands strong & wealthy southern neighbour but was a formidable warrior in his own right - victor over Simon de Montfort at Evesham, conqueror of Wales, he had even been on Crusade.
His intervention had the desired effect. Those male contenders backed down.
Six Guardians of the Realm were appointed (a bit like the Regency Councils we see at different times down in England). A deal was hammered out that Margaret, Maid of Norway, would become engaged to Edward’s son (the future Edward II). The treaty specifically stated that Scotland would remain independent.
Finally in 1290, Margaret set out from Norway to her new kingdom…and died en-rout!
Scotland was thrown into chaos and obviously the wheels had fallen off Edward’s plan to join the royal houses of Scotland and England.
There was no obvious candidate for the crown. In fact over 13 competitors entered the ring including, briefly King Eric of Norway.
A long shot?
Well not when you see the rest!
To find a successor, you had to go back to Alexander’s grandfather - William the Lion, who had died 76 years before. To put that into context, that is like our current Queen dying and having to go back to grandfather, George V to see if he had any brothers or sisters and who was descended form them.
William the Lion did indeed have a younger brother, David Earl of Huntingdon. Long dead of course, but he had 2 daughters, Margaret and Isobel.
Margaret the elder sister, had married an English noble and had a daughter who married another English nobleman, John Balliol, (Lord of Barnard Castle in the north eats of England - and founder of Balliol College at Oxford University).
They had a son, John Balliol.
By the laws of Primogeniture (succession passing through the first born), John Balliol had the strongest claim to the throne of Scotland.
But he didn’t have the only claim.
If you recall, David Earl of Huntingdon, had another daughter, Isobel.
She had married another nobleman, the 4th Lord of Annandale, Robert Bruce.
Don’t get too excited, this isn’t the Robert Bruce you have heard about!
The one that you have heard about is their great-grandson - also Robert Bruce or Robert The Bruce.
And these were the best two candidates! Others included various desc pendants of illegitimate children of William the Lion and even one descended from Donald III (remember him? Donaldbaine? Malcolm Canmore’s brother?)
This horse-trading became now as The Great Cause.
The 6 Guardians of the Realm asked Edward I to adjudicate.
The English King called a Scottish Parliament to meet in York where he demanded that they acknowledge him as their overlord who had the right to choose their king.
Reluctantly they agreed.
Edward then appointed a commission of nobles who would hear the competing cases.
In November 1292 Edward judged that John Balliol (based upon Primogeniture) had the best case and he appointed him king.
If Edward thought that Balliol would be a puppet-king he was to be disappointed. The new Scottish king refused to attend the English parliament (even though he had been one of the nobles who had accepted Edward as overlord) and then in 1295 he signed an alliance with France.
This Auld Alliance stated that France and Scotland would support each other if ever either was at war with England. It was to survive for the rest of Scotland’s independent history and built strong links between France and Scotland - probably more often to French advantage but I guess that is debatable.
The Auld Alliance not withstanding, in 1296 Edward invaded Scotland defeated and deposed Balliol, and symbolically took the Stone of Destiny (the stone upon which Scottish kings were crowned at Scone) back to Westminster Abbey where it would remain until 1996. Finally, living up to his new name “Hammer of the Scots” he garrisoned various Scottish castles with English troops although he made no attempt to annex the country or proclaim himself king.
Once more Scotland was in complete chaos.
This English-enforced chaos was a step too far for the proud Scots.
A rebellion broke in 1297 led by William Wallace (Braveheart).
Later that year Wallace defeated the English at the battle of Stirling Bridge.
When I say defeated, annihilated might be a better term. The English lost about 5,000 of their 9,000 army.
Wallace was now appointed Guardian of Scotland and led raiding parties deep into northern England.
It was time for Edward I to take personal control.
Marching from Berwick via Edinburgh he met Wallace at Falkirk.
Here, the tables were turned and it was William Wallace e who tasted the bitter pill of defeat.
He was forced to relinquish his post of Guardian of the Realm to two nobles who would share the role - one of whom was Robert Bruce (yes, our man!)
William Wallace remained at large, leading a diplomatic mission to France, but in 1305 he was betrayed to the English, captured and taken to London. There, Edward I ordered him to be hung, drawn and quartered.
By 1306, the Guardian of the Realm, Robert Bruce declared himself King at Scone (minus the stone).
By now Edward I was an old man of 67 but once more he took to the field.
Once more the Scots were defeated and Robert Bruce was forced to live as a fugitive in western Scotland.
This is when the legend say Robert Bruce watched a spider spinning its web and was inspired to keep trying just like the spider.
The following year, the old king of England, the “hammer of the Scots” died and was succeeded by his far from warlike son, Edward II.
Bruce seized the opportunity and won a series of victories and by 1314 only Stirling Castle remained in English hands.
Finally, Edward II decided to take action and led an army of 15,000 to relieve the castle.
On the 23rd June 1314, a few miles south of Stirling his huge force found their way blocked by the Scottish army (which was about a third of its size).
What he didn’t have in numbers, bruce made up for in tactics.
He had dug pits 3 foot deep filled with sharpened poles and the English cavalry charged straight into them.
In an attempt to outflank the Scots, Edward ordered his infantry to cross a tidal stream - the Bannock Burn.
Exhausted from this effort the English army set up camp for the night.
The next morning - 24th June the English awoke to find themselves in a confined area with a stream on one side and the burn on the other and behind them.
And it was then that the Scots attacked.
Wary of more traps and unable to manoeuvre in the confined space, Edward’s cavalry were neutralised. As Scottish infantry charged into the English, the invaders suddenly found that the confined space meant that their superior numbers were useless - they were in a tight jam.
As the Scots pressed home their attack, panic started to speed in the English army and they turned to flee only to find that there was now in a tight funnel trying to cross the Bannock Burn.
It turned into a slaughter. It is estimated that the English lost well over 10,000 men whilst Bruce lost a couple of hundred.
Edward fled for his life and Stirling Castle surrendered.
Scotland was free from the English.
In 1320 nearly 50 Scottish nobles signed a letter to the Pope asking him to recognise Scottish independence and Robert Bruce as the lawful king. This Declaration of Arbroath stated:
“As long as but a hundred of us remain alive, never will we on any condition be brought under English rule. It is in truth not for glory, nor riches, not honours, that we are fighting, but for freedom”
Better than anything Mel Gibson shouted in “Braveheart” and unlike the film, this declaration of independence is real - over 400 years before the American declaration too!
As an aside, the Declaration of Arbroath went on to tell the Pope how St. Andrew had supposedly converted the Scots and following this declaration, St. Andrew became the patron saint of Scotland, although it only seems that the flag of St. Andrew was adopted as a Scottish symbol about 60 years later.
Finally in 1328, the Treaty of Edinburgh signed by Bruce and the Treaty of Northampton signed by the new king of England (Edward III) finally brought peace as the English gave up their claim to overlordship. The joint treaties also agreed to the border as it had been established in Alexander III’s time.
As a sign of peace, it was agreed that Edward III’s sister, Joanna, would marry Bruce’s son & heir, David.
A year later, Robert Bruce died and was succeeded by his son David II.
And there our story might end, but not quite….
Those of you who have heard my episode about the Hundred Years War will recognise that Edward III was not like his father. He was more in the mould of granddad, Longshanks. Just like Edward I he was ambitious and he was a warrior.
Edward had come to the throne when he was just 14, after his father was forced to abdicate.
He had signed the Treaty of Northampton in, what is termed his minority. In other words he was king but he was too young to rule in his own right.
So he had guardians (just like Margaret Maid of Norway had earlier in this story). He guardians were his mother Queen Isabella and her lover, Roger Mortimer, and the treaty was their work not his.
By 1332 Edward had reached his majority and promptly reneged on the treaty with the Scots. He encouraged the son of John Balliol (remember him?) to invade and reclaim his father’s lost throne.
Edward Balliol did just this and was crowned king at Scone but King David fought back.
Edward III was forced to enter Scotland with an English army the following year and at Halidon Hill defeated the Scots. David was forced to fly in exile to their partner in the Auld Alliance,France. Edward Balliol was re-installed on the throne and Edward III took most of Lothian (south east Scotland) for England - call it a sort of “finder’s fee”.
Balliol, however, was almost totally dependent on English military support to stay in power and the problem was that Edward III had bigger fish than Scotland to fry. In 1337 he had turned his attention to claiming the throne of France and the Hundred Years War began (see my separate episode all about the period in English history).
With English attention and resources heading ac ross the English Channel, Scots loyal to David of the house of Bruce were able to fight back.
The resistance was led by the High Steward of Scotland, Robert Stewart.
The High Steward was one of the most senior roles in the country, controlling all the domestic administration of the royal household.
Way back in the 12th century (200 years before hand) King David’s namesake, David I, had given this role to a Breton nobleman, Walter Fitz Alan. The title passed down through his family, who changed their name to Steward, until David II’s sister, Marjorie, married the 6th High Steward of Scotland, Walter Steward.
It was their son (and so the exiled king’s nephew) Robert who was leading the fight in what is called the Second War of Scottish Independence.
By 1341 Robert Stewart had driven the English out of Scotland and Balliol was reduced to holding out in the south west corner of Galloway until the 1350’s.
The victory of the High Steward facilitated the return of King David from France.
Meanwhile, the French were having their own problems with the English.
In 1346, Edward had launched an offensive in northern France which resulted in the crushing English victory at Crecy.
True to the Auld Alliance, the French lent on their Scottish friends for some support to take the pressure off them. David, having just been given sanctuary for nearly a decade was honour bound to assist and in the summer of 1346 he invaded England.
Meeting little resistance he advanced as far as Durham where at the battle of Neville’s Cross his army was defeated and he was captured. He was to spend the next 11 years in captivity in England.
Finally in 1157 a peace treaty was signed where the Scots agreed to pay a huge ransom in return for their king’s return.
David continued to reign until he died in 1371.
With no children, the crown passed to his nephew, the High Steward, Robert.
And so it was that Robert was crowned King Robert II and Scotland had a new royal family - the Stewards - and we are going to hear a lot more about them in British history.